Islamabad: A regular client of the International Monetary Fund, investors are asking whether Pakistan’s 13th loan programme since the late 1980s will finally break a cycle of financial crashes and bailouts.
Pakistan’s history of taking the lender’s money while dragging its heels on economic reforms suggest otherwise. With Islamabad now formally requesting IMF aid — seeking to raise anywhere between $6 billion to more than $12 billion — it will also face more scrutiny over debt owed to China. US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has said he will oppose any use of IMF funding to repay loans to Beijing.
“Their conditions will be tougher and we’ll have to pay the price,” said Nadeem Ul Haque, the ex-deputy chairman of Pakistan’s Planning Commission and a former economist at the IMF. “We’ve kept postponing solutions and not taking bold steps — the cancer has been in the body since the 1960s.”
Pakistan has regularly failed to meet conditions attached to its previous IMF loans — for example trimming spending and privatising bloated state-owned corporations. The nation has only ever managed to successfully complete one IMF programme, meaning it received all the disbursements as planned, on a $6.6 billion three-year facility that ended in 2016. Even then, a number of requirements, were relaxed.
Economists have pointed to decades of inaction against widespread tax dodging across all levels of society handing the country one of the lowest tax-to-GDP ratios in Asia. In addition, the country has failed to revamp key export industries, such as textiles — which have lost out to regional neighbours like Bangladesh — or fix an energy system straining under more than 1 trillion rupees ($7.6 billion) of debt.
“Pakistan needs to work on structural problems now so they can avoid another IMF programme,” said Kimihide Ando, the chief executive officer of Mitsubishi Corp’s Pakistan unit. “It’s just sheer will. The solutions are known including industrialisation that has been declining in Pakistan.”
The current crisis has been exacerbated by China’s Belt and Road initiative. Beijing has been criticised by some for pushing countries like Pakistan — which has taken opaque Chinese financing for road and power plants projects of more than $60 billion — into a debt trap.
The projects have meant imports to South Asia’s second-largest economy have surged. In turn Pakistan’s current-account and budget gaps have swelled to more than 5 per cent of gross domestic product and foreign-currency reserves have plunged to the lowest in almost four years. In response authorities have devalued the rupee five times since December and hiked interest rates the most in Asia.
The US is also watching. “Part of the reason that Pakistan found itself in this situation is Chinese debt,” State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert told reporters in Washington on Thursday. “This is something that we’ve been tracking fairly closely.”
Elected in July and promising to roll out an “Islamic welfare state,” Prime Minister Imran Khan was reluctant to turn to the IMF. He criticised previous administrations for going to the lender and promised to break the “begging bowl” habit. Instead, the former cricket legend has been seeking funds from China, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, but with little success.
Muhammad Aurangzeb, the chief executive officer of Habib Bank Ltd, said IMF aid will provide some “breathing space” but the tough part will be narrowing the twin deficits.
“We see all the signals coming from the new government, including the pronouncements that’s been made by the finance minister, that they are going to make some very, very tough political choices,” he said in an interview in Bali on the sidelines of the IMF-World Bank annual meeting. “And if that is done, then we do have a sustainable path to not get back into an IMF programme.”
There are signs Khan’s government will take a reform programme more seriously after making early concessions. This week monetary authorities devalued the rupee the most in two decades after long-standing IMF observations that the currency was overvalued. Finance Minister Asad Umar told Bloomberg in August he will publish the terms of the Chinese loans.
“Getting the house order is painful, but I assure you we will see better days,” Khan told businessmen in Islamabad on Tuesday.
The government is also being pressured by a domineering military that has made unprecedented statements about Pakistan’s economic quandary in the past year. At a Karachi business conference last month, Major General Muhammad Samrez Salik said Pakistan’s economy had suffered from “negligence and incompetence” and highlighted that the country was “lagging behind in developing our economic cooperation” with Asia. Salik compared Pakistan’s $6 billion regional trade with arch-rival India’s $72 billion and added he believed Khan’s administration would drive commerce with Asia as relations with the West sour.
The army’s worries have increased after US President Donald Trump cut military aid to Pakistan earlier this year. Trump raged that Pakistan was continuing to support terrorist groups.
“Trump is no fan of Pakistan,” Charles Robertson, chief economist at Renaissance Capital in London, said in a report on Tuesday. “We heard in the summer that the IMF had already warned in 2016 that — after being fairly generous to Pakistan during the last programme “”- if it was invited back, it would have to go hard-core with Pakistan.”