Poor quality cladding tiles for buildings pose fire hazard

Expert cites lack of adequate building codes for exteriors of high-rises

Last updated:
2 MIN READ
1.1018767-82501251
Oliver Clarke/Gulf News
Oliver Clarke/Gulf News

Dubai A lack of adequate and up-to-date building codes for the exterior construction of high-rise buildings is adding to concerns that poor quality cladding is posing a significant fire hazard.

Only Abu Dhabi has an adequate written building code, while the other emirates have hastily-written regulations, Gulf News has learnt.

"The building codes and regulations seem to cover the insides of buildings quite well, but the exterior seems to have been missed," says Tom Bell-Wright, a consultant engineer who operates the only fire-safety and testing laboratory in the region.

Only about 10 per cent of the buildings constructed are actually tested to ensure that the materials used in the construction of their exteriors can stand up to the rigours of their lifespan," he says.

He points out that his company, for example, would never recommend to its clients that the materials used in the exterior of buildings were not fire resistant. "There is no legal requirement in the UAE [for that]," he says.

Call for ban

Alarm bells over the type of cladding used on high-rise buildings were raised when a twin tower project in Doha went up in flames in May 2006.

"We realised then that this cladding, which was relatively new then, was the problem that caused the flames to spread. We have been calling on a ban of non-flame retardant cladding since then."

Gulf News tested three cladding tiles at Bell-Wright's laboratory. The most commonly-used tile in the UAE and across the region burnt with relative ease when placed next to a small disposable barbecue. It's the same quality tile that covered the exteriors of the Al Baker and Al Tayer Towers in Sharjah that recently went up in flames.

Within seven minutes of being set on fire, the tile had buckled and was wicking heat upwards. After ten minutes of the non-scientific test, the fire-resistant tile only shows superficial smoke markings and is 13 degrees Celsius lower in temperature than the non fire-proof tile.

"You haven't even begun to look at the rest of the materials used in exterior construction," Bell-Wright says. "There's the blackjack sealant paint which is bitumen based.

"And then there's the insulation used between the cladding exterior and the building itself. How fire resistant are those materials?"

Non-fireproof: The brown tile is fire-rated as LDPE (low-density polyethylene) – it is a sandwich of petroleum basedmaterial sandwiched betweenaluminium covering. The non fireratedgrade is most commonly used inthe UAE and across the region. Afterseven minutes, the tile showed anexterior temperature of 85 degreesCelsius. It buckled at first, its sidesbending outwards. The material alsobegan to allow flames and heat tomove closer to its surface, and in ahigh-rise scenario would have allowedfor greater spread of flames. It caughtfire after 8 minutes, and its materialbegan to ooze and drip.
Fire-retardant: The beige tile is rated as B1 – havingthe ability to withstand flames,though it will catch fire and allow theflames to spread. When measuredwith a hand-held thermometer gunafter seven minutes, the surfacetemperature was at 77 degreesCelsius. Its surface also showed signsof bending, as with the B2 sample.It did not catch fire within the tenminutes of testing resting next toand on a small disposable barbeque.Other than the buckle and smokemarkings, it withstood the nonscientifictest.
Fire-res istant: The red tile is rated as A2 – havingthe ability to withstand flames andmaintain its integrity for a prolongedperiod. After seven minutes rest nextto and on a small disposable barbeque,it’s exterior temperature registered 72degree Celsius. Like the other threesamples, it was squirted several timeswith barbeque fuel. The fuel caught fireand did cause blackening of the surface,but there was no obvious damage.Unlike the other two samples, it showedno visible signs of buckling or bendingduring 10 minutes of being adjacent toand on a small disposable barbeque.

Sign up for the Daily Briefing

Get the latest news and updates straight to your inbox