Abu Dhabi: Lebanese analysts said the final destination of the Moldovan-flagged MV Rhosus was Beirut and not Mozambique, following conflicting reports of how the deadly ship ended up in the capital.
Luqman Salim, a Lebanese political analyst, said that the stories about how the ship arrived in Beirut - due to technical defects and that it was seized for non-payment of debts, in addition to the way the judiciary and security dealt with the deadly shipment - show that the final destination of it was Beirut, and not Mozambique.
Lebanon’s government has blamed the huge blast that devastated parts of Beirut on the detonation of 2,750 tonnes of ammonium nitrate stored at the city’s port.
A fire appears to have triggered the detonation of the ammonium nitrate the next day. The blast killed at least 137 people and injured about 5,000 others, while dozens are still missing.
In statements to Al Hurra, Salim added that what happened after the ship arrived and the ammonium nitrate shipment was stored in the port indicate that it was a complicated process to cover up the final destination of the shipment, which was certainly not Mozambique, as some reports claim.
Regarding the owner of this shipment in Beirut, Salim said the party, which was, and still is, controlling the port and security and has a long arm in the judicial apparatus inside Lebanon is Hezbollah, and it is likely that the party is the one behind the import of this shipment.
Salim did not conceal that a large part of the Lebanese people had lost confidence in the Lebanese judiciary and security since 2005, that is, after the assassination of former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, affirming that any investigation outcome that would emerge after the Beirut blasts would be subject to doubts.
He called for setting up an international investigation committee to get to the truth.
Lebanese people have expressed anger and disbelief that such a large quantity of potentially explosive material was kept inside a warehouse without any safety measures for more than six years, so close to the centre of the city.
Russian-owned cargo ship
The government has not named the source of the ammonium nitrate, but the chemical arrived in Beirut in November 2013 on the Russian-owned cargo ship.
Embroiled in a financial and diplomatic dispute, the vessel was abandoned by the Russian businessman who had leased it. The ammonium nitrate was transferred to a dockside warehouse in Beirut, where it would languish for years, until Tuesday, when Lebanese officials said it exploded.
The story of the ship and its deadly cargo, which emerged on Wednesday in accounts from Lebanon, Russia and Ukraine, offered a bleak tale about how legal battles, financial wrangling and, apparently, chronic negligence, set the stage for a horrific accident that devastated one of the Middle East’s most popular countries.
The vessel was reported to have set sail that September from Batumi, Georgia, heading to Beira, Mozambique.
It was carrying 2,750 tonnes of ammonium nitrate, which typically comes in the form of small pellets that are widely used as agricultural fertiliser but can also be mixed with fuel oil to make explosives for the mining and construction industries.
While sailing through the eastern Mediterranean the Rhosus reportedly suffered “technical problems” and was forced to dock at Beirut’s port, according to a 2015 report for industry newsletter Shippingarrested.com that was written by Lebanese lawyers who represented the crew.
The Rhosus was inspected by port officials and “forbidden from sailing”, the lawyers said. Most of the crew were repatriated, except for the Russian captain, Boris Prokoshev, and three others, who were reportedly Ukrainians.
Prokoshev told Reuters on Thursday that the Rhosus was leaking but seaworthy at the time, and that it was sent to Beirut by its owner to take on an additional cargo of heavy equipment because of financial difficulties.
However, the crew could not load the equipment safely, and when the ship’s owner failed to pay the port fees, the Lebanese authorities impounded it, he said.
Shortly afterwards, the Rhosus was “abandoned by its owners after charterers and cargo concern lost interest in the cargo”, according to the lawyers. It was also subject to legal claims from creditors.
Meanwhile, the crew still confined to the vessel were running out of food and supplies. The lawyers said they applied to the Judge of Urgent Matters in Beirut for an order authorising them to return home, emphasising “the danger the crew was facing given the ‘dangerous’ nature of the cargo” in the ship’s holds.
The judge eventually agreed to allow the crew to disembark and in 2014 the port authorities transferred the ammonium nitrate into “Warehouse 12”, next to the grain silos. The lawyers said the cargo was “awaiting auctioning and/or proper disposal”.
“The cargo was highly explosive. That’s why it was kept on board when we were there... That ammonium nitrate had a very high concentration,” Prokoshev said.
He added: “I feel sorry for the people [killed or injured by the explosion]. But local authorities, the Lebanese, should be punished. They did not care about the cargo at all.”
However, the Beirut port’s general manager, Hassan Koraytem, and the director general of Lebanese Customs, Badri Daher, both said on Wednesday that they and other officials repeatedly warned the judiciary about the danger posed by the stored ammonium nitrate and the need to remove it.
Documents circulated online appeared to show that customs officials sent letters to a Judge of Urgent Matters in Beirut seeking guidance on how to sell or dispose of it at least six times from 2014 to 2017.
Koraytem told local channel OTV that State Security also sent warning letters.
Public Works Minister Michel Najjar, who took office at the start of this year, told Al Jazeera that he only learned about the presence of the ammonium nitrate in late July and that he spoke to Koraytem about the matter on Monday.
President Michel Aoun said the failure to deal with the Rhosus’ cargo was “unacceptable” and promised to “hold those responsible and those who were negligent accountable, and serve them the most severe punishment”.
The government has ordered a dozen officials, involved in storing or guarding the ammonium nitrate, to be put under house arrest pending an investigation.