Classifieds powered by Gulf News

Qatar aid breeds sceptism

Critics allege Doha’s short-term goal is to prop up Brotherhood ahead of elections

Image Credit:
A protester who opposes President Mohammad Mursi, holds a sign criticising Qatar and Israelduring a rally at the courthouse near Tahrir Square in Cairo in March.
Gulf News

Cairo: Qatar, a tiny country which has wielded oversize influence in revolutions across the Middle East, is now at the centre of a battle for clout in the region’s traditional military and political juggernaut, Egypt.

On May 9, Qatar released $3 billion (Dh11.01 billion) in low-interest loans to Egypt, the latest in a total of $8 billion in assistance it has provided in the past two years to Cairo’s Muslim Brotherhood-led government.

The move, which the government didn’t announce, was confirmed by a central bank official.

While many Egyptians are grateful for the cash, some worry that Qatar’s support of Egypt’s Islamist-leaning government marks Qatar’s latest attempt to gain influence in the region. Such suspicions have fuelled Qatar flag-burnings in Egypt in recent weeks — protests echoed by rallies in Libya, Tunisia and the Palestinian territories against Qatari meddling.

Many countries are seeking a stake in Egypt, said Abdul Moati Zaki Ebrahim, a founder of the Freedom and Justice Party, the Brotherhood’s political arm. “We are the gateway to the Middle East,” said Ebrahim, who is also an executive of the FJP’s political affairs committee.

Asked whether he was worried about Qatar trying to influence Egypt politically, Ebrahim said: “If the big powers aren’t working, why shouldn’t the little powers fill [the gap]? There’s an old saying: Someone asks a cat, ‘Why are you behaving like a lion? And the cat says, ‘because the lion is behaving like a cat’.” Qatar’s lifeline has allowed Cairo’s embattled government to hold off, for now, on agreeing to a $4.8 billion International Monetary Fund loan — one that would require it to slash social programmes just ahead of elections slated for later this year.

The Qatari aid underscores how Egypt, suffering from steep economic declines, is looking well beyond its traditional backers in Washington. In recent weeks, Egyptian President Mohammad Mursi has been seen “begging” for money in stately visits from Moscow to Doha, his opponents say, hurting the pride of a nation that has long seen itself as the region’s kingmaker.

Egypt is striving to have good relations with the world, counters Brotherhood spokesman Jihad Al Haddad, adding that Cairo’s previous dictatorial regime hurt the country by throwing its weight behind one power. “We no longer have a single ally called the United States. We have a menu of possible allies,” he said.

Critics allege that while Doha’s near-term goal appears to be to prop up the Brotherhood before elections, its longer-term aims are less clear.

“Egyptians aren’t stupid — they know this isn’t money given because Qatar is grateful for our historical contributions to the region, but because [Qatar] is mysterious and wants something,” said Hamdeen Sabahi, a secular opposition leader of the National Salvation Front who finished in third place in Egypt’s presidential elections last year.

“Egyptians feel that Qatar is not supporting them as a whole but [rather] the Muslim Brotherhood,” he said in a recent interview at his home.

The Qatari Embassy in Cairo and its foreign-affairs ministry in Doha didn’t respond to requests to comment. Criticism of Qatar’s role in Egypt boils down to opposition forces “that can’t attack their president, [so] they are attacking Qatar for helping,” said Nasser Bin Hamad Al Khalifa, Qatar’s former ambassador to the US.


Ties to Brotherhood

Many of the concerns centre on how Qatar has leveraged its historically deep ties with the Brotherhood, an expansive regional movement long suppressed by Egypt and other governments. Since early 2011, Qatar led a push to aid and arm Islamist-leaning rebel factions in Libya and Syria. It has also continued to support Brotherhood’s Palestinian branch, Hamas, designated by the US as a terrorist organisation. When Hamas broke with its long-time ally Syrian President Bashar Al Assad and threw its support behind Syria’s rebels, the group moved its headquarters from Damascus to the Qatari capital, Doha, marking a major shift in the region’s political dynamics.

American officials have long worried that Qatar is playing a double game — hosting a US military base but also supporting Islamist movements that are opposed to American interests. By supporting so many sides, US officials have said, Qatar is able to navigate the Middle East’s complex political networks and support whichever movement stands to come out on top.

Qatar is locked in a battle for clout with Saudi Arabia, another traditional Sunni power in the region — which, alongside the United Arab Emirates, has historically opposed the Brotherhood in the region and has clashed with Mursi’s government.

Russia, too, is considering a “sizable” loan to Egypt after Mursi visited Moscow last month, according to Russian and Egyptian officials. As the regime of President Al Assad slips in Syria — one of Russia’s only Arab allies, and the host to a Russian naval base — Moscow may see Cairo as a new avenue for influence.