On a cloudless spring afternoon, thousands of parents, teachers and alumni watched as a pack of young students charged across a field, screaming and snarling, and then crashed into a wall of students defending an 11.8-foot wooden pole. The attackers clawed, shoved and jumped over the opposition. Heads butted. Elbows were thrown. The wall buckled, then stood firm. Like a mast on a sailboat in rough seas, the pole dipped, then rose again.
This wasn’t trench warfare, it was botaoshi, a century-old game that combines elements of football, rugby, sumo and martial arts. The game has gotten so dangerous that many Japanese schools have abandoned it, but it lives on at Kaisei Gakuen, where it is the centrepiece of the school’s annual sports festival.
Little known outside Japan, botaoshi, or “topple the pole,” remains a rite of passage at Kaisei, which opened in 1871 and is one of Japan’s most prestigious secondary schools. Teachers say the game promotes teamwork, toughness and sportsmanship. Students eagerly await their chance to compete in the tournament in their junior and senior years. (Underclassmen play more rudimentary games.) Alumni can recount details of games played decades ago.
“Since my first year in junior high school, I was watching my senpai,” Makoto Nakagawa, a recent Kaisei graduate, said of his upperclassmen. “The image of botaoshi was at the centre of everything. It’s a tradition.”
To the uninitiated, botaoshi looks like mass chaos. At one end of a field, two dozen attackers try to pull down a pole while two dozen defenders try to keep it upright.
At the other end of the field, the mirror image unfolds in real time, except the attackers are on the same team as the defenders 50 or so feet away, and the defenders are teammates with the attackers.
The first team to lower the tip of the pole to below 140 centimetres from the ground within 90 seconds is the winner. If neither team succeeds, they start over. If the second game ends in a draw, the tie is broken with a lottery.
At Kaisei, the attackers and defenders wear colourful headbands and pump each other up with throat-clearing chants like “Fight to the finish!” and “Win at all costs!”
The players wear little protective gear besides soft helmets, kneepads and athletic cups. Sprains, cuts and bloody noses are common and accepted. Every so often, students may fracture leg bones, vertebrae and cheekbones or suffer a concussion.
After practice, students pile into the nurse’s office for ice packs and bandages.
The number of injuries in botaoshi has risen in recent years. According to school records, the number of injuries jumped 52 per cent from 2005 to 2016, the most recent year for which records were available.
The increase can partly be attributed to better reporting, said Tetsuo Shimizu, a longtime math teacher at the school and a spokesman for the festival, but also to a gap between athletically inclined students and an increasing number drawn to other pursuits but who also participate in botaoshi.
“Students who are in sports clubs and students in art and literature clubs who never do sports are all mixed together,” said Satoshi Matsumoto, a Kaisei graduate and doctor who volunteered at the sports festival. “It is impressive that there are no serious accidents.”
Botaoshi has been a part of Kaisei’s sports festival since 1929, although the game was created years before.
Minoru Matsunami, a sports historian at Tokai University, said botaoshi might be a combination of several recreational games popular in the 1890s, such as sao nobori (pole climbing), hata tori (capture the flag) and tsuna nobori hata tori (climbing a rope and grabbing a piece of cloth).
He said another theory is that botaoshi was modelled after a version of capture the flag, or taisho tori, except a flag was on top of a pole. The game was played by students in Kagoshima in southern Japan who may have brought it to the naval academy in Hiroshima prefecture. It may be the origin of the botaoshi still played at the National Defense Academy.
Conditions were rougher years ago. At Kaisei, games would typically last about five minutes, and ties would result in endless replays, so tournaments stretched into the night. Students wore little protective gear. Rules were printed on a few pages.
“We didn’t have any meticulous game plan like in American football,” said Akito Hattori, who graduated from Kaisei in 1977 and broke his clavicle as a defender playing botaoshi. “It was more savage and loose.”
Shin Sone, his best friend from that era who was an attacker in botaoshi, was blunter. “It was just a head-on fight,” he said.
(The version of botaoshi played at the defence academy is more violent. Defenders stand on their teammates’ shoulders. One defender sits atop the pole and kicks attackers.)
By the 1980s, parents pushed their children to focus more on college entrance exams and became concerned that botaoshi and other physical games like kumitaiso, which involves building a human pyramid, and kibasen, akin to chicken fights or a mock cavalry battle, were too dangerous. Schools began dropping them from their festivals.
Three years ago, a student at Azabu Gakuen, another well-known all-boys school in Tokyo, was hit so hard he was taken to a hospital in an ambulance. He did not suffer a spinal injury, as feared, but the school ultimately chose to drop the game.
“Some teachers were concerned that the game might have reached a threshold,” Hideaki Taira, the school’s headmaster, said.
The question is why, in the age of helicopter parents, a game that causes so much mayhem endures at Kaisei while other schools have abandoned it.
Young boys play football, hockey and other contact sports. But they wear protective gear, and the danger is tolerated in part because the best athletes can earn college scholarships.
Botaoshi, by contrast, is played only at the sports festival, or undokai, which is woven into the fabric of the school. Students spend months practicing and planning for it. Alumni said fighting shirtless in close quarters broke down barriers and built bonds, and spoke of Kaisei Kenji, the toughness of Kaisei students.
Matsunami, the sports historian who has played botaoshi and football, said the game remains a good way to teach teamwork and build stamina, even if it looks chaotic.
“If you watched American football before the NCAA was formed, without knowing about its history and rules, a lot of people would think it’s crazy,” he said. “It’s the same thing.”
Yukio Yanagisawa, Kaisei’s headmaster, acknowledged botaoshi’s risks. But he and others at the school say the game is far safer now because the rules have been changed.
Kicking, for instance, is not permitted at Kaisei. Games were reduced to 90 seconds, from two minutes, in 1998. The length that attackers run to reach defenders was shortened from 30 metres to 10 metres to reduce the severity of collisions.
Some students said they still feared being hurt. But they were confident the game would endure at the school.
“Every year, if a very serious accident happens, we come up with some countermeasures and revise the rules,” said Ryuta Ishikawa, the captain of the team that won this year’s tournament.
While concerned, many parents accept the game.
“It is dangerous, but I trust them because their rules are very detailed and reviewed each year,” said Yuichi Higuchi, who took time off work to see his son, a senior, take the field. “I want him to come back without any injuries.”
Unlike many Japanese schools, students at Kaisei are given a lot of autonomy to run the sports festival. For months, they plan all the logistics of the event, refine the game rules and devise strategies to win. The festival’s rule book, written in a tiny Japanese font, is 124 pages.
“The teachers trust us and let us do what we want freely,” said Sotaro Yokoi, a junior and a chief umpire. But, he added, the teachers will step in if someone gets seriously hurt.
Botaoshi is a simple game. Yet Kaisei students spend a lot of time plotting strategy. Attackers are divided into three main groups. The first six or so try to clear a path to the pole by pushing away defenders. The second wave jumps over defenders to grab the pole. The third group pulls the legs of teammates who have grabbed the pole, hoping to lower it further. It also pulls away defenders trying to drag down teammates.
Before the whistle that starts the game, the first wave of attackers marches toward midfield in a tight-knit scrum so the defenders cannot identify who will lead the charge. This group usually includes taller students who have the greatest chance of grabbing the pole.
The defenders align in concentric circles. A first inner ring of three defenders holds the pole. Another three defenders sit and hold the base of the pole. A third layer of eight defenders crouch with their backs to the inner ring of teammates, and lock arms. The remaining defenders form a wider ring to repel attackers or pull down attackers who reach the pole.
Much of the strategy involves deciding how many attackers to throw at the pole, and in what patterns. Some teams favor a frontal assault. Others send attackers from different points around the pole. Teams videotape their practices. The strategies are kept secret and are passed on to underclassmen.
One unique feature of botaoshi is that attackers are unaware of how their teammates are doing at the other end of the field, and vice versa.
“We just think about executing our plan perfectly, so during the 90-second game, instead of thinking, we just do what we should do,” said Masato Takubo, a senior and the captain of one of the teams.
Students are divided into eight teams, each named for a colour. The winner must capture three matches in a row.
The excitement this year was palpable. “Old boys” stood near the grandstands for the teams they once played on. Parents screamed encouragement to their sons. Underclassmen, led by cheerleaders, chanted fight songs.
The screams got louder when attackers started pulling down a pole and defenders rushed underneath and used their shoulders to keep it aloft. Gasps could be heard each time an attacker launched himself over the defenders and reached the pole. More cheers rose when defenders pulled the attackers away.
In the final match, time expired before the yellow and purple teams could topple the pole. Judges measured the distance of the poles from the ground and ruled that the yellow team had won. The championship theirs, the winners threw their helmets in the air and ran a victory lap in jubilation.
–New York Times News Service