One Punch Man 3 controversy breakdown: Overworked studios, animation woes, and fan harassment

The core controversy

• Season 1 was animated by Madhouse, a studio renowned for its stunning visuals and fluid fight scenes. Season 2 shifted to J.C. Staff, a studio. The result: a massive drop in animation quality that many fans deemed unacceptable.

• Season 3, released on October 12, has continued the trend, with animation described as “PowerPoint-level,” static, and lacking the excitement and humor that defined the series. Key scenes, like Garou sliding down a hill, have been mocked online for their “slideshow-style” execution.

Why fans are furious:

• The series’ identity was built on spectacular fights and comedic timing; both are severely undercut in the new season.

• Fans had some hope J.C. Staff could redeem themselves after Season 2, but early episodes of Season 3 show no improvement, leading to disappointment and online outrage.

• Some fans even tried using AI tools to fix the visuals, highlighting the severity of dissatisfaction.

The bullying and backlash

• Animator Shinpei Nagai, revealed as Season 3’s director, faced harassment online even before the season aired. Fans questioned his experience, prompting him to post a detailed resume defending his credentials.

• After the episodes released, backlash intensified, fueled by memes and social media critics. The harassment became so severe that Nagai deactivated his X (Twitter) account, citing the impact on his mental health and the production team’s morale.

• Industry experts stressed that animators in Japan are often overworked and underpaid, and harassment can harm future productions rather than improve quality.

Production challenges:

• J.C. Staff reportedly had time and management issues, and unlike studios like Ufotable, which carefully plan and execute high-quality sequences, OPM’s animation suffered from rushed production.

• Season 3 is working under similar constraints as Season 2, including underwhelming sound design and uneven pacing.

The verdict?

• Season 3 has failed to live up to the standard set by Season 1, leaving fans disappointed but should not justify harassment of the staff.

• While the series’ characters and story remain engaging for some, the lack of visual excellence means One-Punch Man is no longer the power e it once was.

• The staff had advised fansto to temper expectations, appreciate the creative effort where possible, and focus on healthier fandom engagement instead of targeting animators.