Emmy snubs and surprises: ‘Squid Game,’ ‘This Is Us’

The Emmy Award nominations announced Tuesday included some snubs and surprises. ‘This Is Us’ and ‘black-ish’ will walk away forever limply and Nathan Lane made history as the most-nominated best comedy guest actor in Emmy history.

HBO’s ‘Succession’ (pictured) topped this year’s Emmy nominations, earning 25 nods, as ‘Squid Game’ became the first non-English-language drama series shortlisted for glory for television’s equivalent of the Oscars.

‘Succession,’ which follows a rich, powerful family vying to inherit a media empire, led the drama nominees, while ‘Ted Lasso’ and ‘The White Lotus’ (pictured) topped the comedy and limited series categories with 20 nominations each.

Two other comedies — HBO’s ‘Hacks’ (pictured) and Hulu’s ‘Only Murders in the Building’ — each racked up 17 nominations for the 74th Emmy Awards, to be handed out at a glitzy ceremony in Los Angeles on September 12. Here’s our rundown of the snubs and surprises at this year’s noms.

NOT JUST A GAME: ‘Squid Game,’ the brutal Netflix survival drama about desperate adults competing in deadly children’s games for a chance to escape debt, won in its bid to become the first non-English-language drama series ever nominated for top drama. In the bleak and disturbing series from South Korea, hundreds of men and women on the brink of financial ruin compete in a deadly battle for roughly $38 million in cash.

Every game is a traditional Korean children’s game such as Red Light, Green Light, but the consequence of losing is death. The winner is the person who outlasts all opponents. It remains Netflix’s most popular series. ‘Squid Game’ became the first series to cross the streamer’s 1 billion hours-viewed mark and was awarded 14 Emmy nods in its freshman year. The cultural impact of the show was nearly immediate. People dressed as the pink-jumpsuited ‘Squid Game’ guards for Halloween, TikTok challenges launched and memes filled social media.

The success of ‘Squid Game’ comes three years after the South Korean film ‘Parasite’ won best picture at the Oscars, overcoming what its director Bong Joon-ho called the “one-inch barrier of subtitles.”

FAREWELL, US: This may make ‘This Is Us’ fans cry: The show will go into the TV sunset without ever having won the Emmy for outstanding drama series. The NBC tearjerker has won Emmys for actors Gerald McRaney, Sterling K. Brown and Ron Cephas Jones but has never been crowned best drama. This past season was the show’s sixth and final one, and it picked up a single nomination this time, for outstanding original music and lyrics, not exactly a rousing goodbye.

‘This Is Us’ tells the story of the Pearson family across multiple generations via flashbacks, present-day stories and flash-forwards. It premiered on NBC in 2016 starring Mandy Moore, Milo Ventimiglia, Chrissy Metz, Justin Hartley and Brown.

While some groused that the series was manipulative and overly soap opera-ish, it dealt with real issues like the loss of a parent, struggles with pregnancy, depression, drug addiction, Alzheimer’s disease, obesity, coming out and interracial adoption. The show has been nominated multiple times for best drama — 2021, 2019, 2018 and 2017 — but lost to shows like ‘Game of Thrones,’ ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ and ‘The Crown.’

LAUGHING MATTER? Dave Chappelle’s 2021 special ‘The Closer’ which included hate comments, was nominated for best variety special and directing for a variety special. Netflix ran into a buzz-saw of criticism not only with the special but in how internal memos responded to employees’ concerns. Netflix employees at one point walked out in protest.

But co-CEO Ted Sarandos wrote that Netflix doesn’t allow titles that are “designed to incite hate or violence, and we don’t believe ‘The Closer’ crosses that line.” Critics said that while the streaming service offers positive fare, Netflix is having it both ways by also offering a show like Chappelle’s that includes disparaging comments. Louis C.K.’s ‘Sorry’ in 2021 was his second self-released special since his career slowed down after admitting to sexual misconduct. It did not move Emmy voters.

LASSOING NODS STAYS STEADY A dip this year after a romp last year was perfectly understandable, but ‘Ted Lasso,’ the most nominated freshman comedy series in history, kept up the scoring with Emmy voters. The Jason Sudeikis-led comedy earned 20 nods, the same number of nominations for ‘Ted Lasso’ last year in its debut season, on its way to eventually winning seven trophies, including outstanding comedy series and lead actor for Sudeikis.

The show centres on an American football coach who takes charge of an elite British soccer team in England despite having little knowledge of the game. Sudeikis’ Lasso may be a fish out of water, but he’s relentlessly optimistic and kind, armed with homespun wisdom in the face of hostility.

If the first season established the characters and the tone, the second was about deepening and exploring what the creators have already built, with many secondary characters finding their voices. The dedication to fleshing out characters meant the second season largely abandoned the overall plot machine of the club’s success. The third season — expected to be the last — is already in the works. The show’s success may be due in part because the world is reeling from the devastating effects of COVID-19 and Lasso’s homespun slogans and kindness in the face of adversity seem to touch a nerve.

‘ONLY MURDERS’ KILLS IT Hulu’s buzzy true crime satire ‘Only Murders in the Building’ was eligible for the first time this year and slayed with 17 nominations, including writing and outstanding comedy. It may have helped that stars Martin Short, Steve Martin and Selena Gomez were already appearing in the show’s second season during much of Emmy voting. Short and Martin earned acting nods — Gomez didn’t get one of those but has a producer credit nomination.

In the first season, the three played true crime podcast fans who solved a murder in their apartment building on New York City’s Upper West Side, creating a popular podcast in the process. In the second season, Gomez’s character has been accused of killing the building’s board president. Martin, who plays a washed-up actor, and Short, a faded stage director, want to prove her innocence.

Helping the show along are plenty of guest stars, including Tina Fey (pictured), Amy Schumer, Da’Vine Joy Randolph, Jaboukie Young-White, Jackie Hoffman, Jayne Houdyshell, Nathan Lane, Amy Ryan, Ali Stroker and Sting. But much of the show’s success is due to the chemistry between the three leads, what BuzzFeed called “the terrific trio we never knew we needed.”

STAYING IN HIS LANE: Nathan Lane has made history as the most-nominated best comedy guest actor in Emmy history. The three-time Tony winner outmuscled the late Fred Willard for the most nominations in the category for his work on ‘Only Murders in the Building,’ leaving him with six nods to Willard’s five.

Lane has yet to win a Primetime Emmy, though he is the recipient of two Daytime Emmys for his voice work in ‘Timon and Pumbaa’ and ‘Teacher’s Pet.’ He has been nominated for best comedy guest actor six times and best drama guest actor once. The previous comedy bids were for his work on sitcoms ‘Frasier,’ ‘Mad About You’ and ‘Modern Family.’

In ‘Only Murders in the Building,’ Lane plays a deli chain owner/podcast sponsor who is harboring dark secrets. Lane has won Tonys for the Broadway shows ‘Angels in America,’ ‘The Producers’ and ‘A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum.’ He also has a Screen Actors Guild for his work in ‘The Birdcage.’

AN ELEMENTARY CHOICE: Network TV is dead — or is it? ‘Abbott Elementary’ once again proves it is not. The hilarious mockumentary became ABC’s first comedy to quadruple its ratings since its premiere, and it nabbed seven nominations. ‘Abbott Elementary’ follows a documentary crew while they film the lives of teachers and students at a struggling, underfunded Philadelphia school. It earned nominations for outstanding comedy series, comedy writing, casting and acting for Tyler James Williams, Janelle James and Sheryl Lee Ralph.

It was created and written by comedian Quinta Brunson, who plays Janine Teagues and also earned an acting nod Tuesday. She previously appeared in ‘A Black Lady Sketch Show’ and ‘Big Mouth,’ and is currently working on the script for the second season of ‘Abbott Elementary.’ It airs on Disney+ in the UAE. ‘Abbott Elementary’ is a true workplace comedy in the vein of ‘The Office’ or ‘Superstore’ and achieved ABC’s highest ratings since the ‘Modern Family’ finale. At one point, it was the most tweeted-about TV comedy of the year. TV Guide in June called it the best show on television right now, saying it is “revitalising the network sitcom by shrinking the distinction between broadcast and streaming.”

A SAD GOODBYE-ISH: Fans of ‘black-ish’ may feel aggrieved that Emmy love never came, even at the end. The show — a vehicle for nuanced chapters about racism, parenthood, sexism and police violence all within a comedy — ended its eight-season run this year without ever winning the outstanding comedy series crown or trophies for lead actors Tracee Ellis Ross and Anthony Anderson.

The series earned a prestigious Peabody Award and other awards — including multiple NAACP Image Awards — but top Emmys remained out of reach. It got one, for hairstyling, in 2020. This year it got two nominations: hairstyling and costumes. The series was a network TV rarity: A depiction of a prosperous, tight-knit family of color, the Johnsons, with Black creators shaping their stories. Anderson did score an impressive seven best comedy actor nominations in a row, plus four additional bids for producing when ‘black-ish’ earned best comedy series nominations in 2016, 2017, 2018 and 2021.

‘SEVERANCE’ NOT CUT OFF: ‘Severance,’ Apple TV+’s vicious satire of office culture, managed to charm Emmy voters with 14 nominations. ‘Severance’ is set in a shadowy corporate headquarters where employees have agreed to get a chip implanted in their brains that separates the personal life from office life. Though conceived before the pandemic, it arrived just as many white-collar workers were making their first tentative steps back to the office — and questioning why. The show — written by newcomer Dan Erickson, with all episodes directed by Ben Stiller and Aoife McArdle — is drenched in paranoia about what corporate work does to people and became one of the most acclaimed series of the year.

Adam Scott stars as the leader of a group who work under bright florescent lights and wander down endless antiseptic corridors, cut off from the world outside. In Season One, the series morphs from satire to thriller as some employees start questioning what is happening to them. Among the show’s nominations are a berth in top drama series and a best writing honour. Scott earned a lead actor nod, Patricia Arquette got one as a supporting actor and Stiller for directing the episode ‘The We We Are.’