Attention rock stars: No matter how much you want to, resist at all costs orchestrating your songs.
Almost without fail, it is the wrong call.
Case in point: Neil Young’s latest effort, Storytone.
Thankfully, Young has done listeners the favour of presenting the songs both with full orchestration and solo acoustic. The single disc version is with orchestration and on three songs, a big band, while the solo acoustic takes are available in a deluxe double-disc release.
Not that the orchestrated versions are a complete failure, it’s just that taken as a whole Storytone works best, and packs a bigger emotional punch, when Young sticks with the more familiar acoustic guitar and piano.
At its worst, as heard on the environmental battle cry Who’s Gonna Stand Up, the orchestration sounds like something out of Pirates of the Caribbean. Protesting against fracking just feels right with a guitar backing, not a 92-piece orchestra.
Most often, less is more on Storytone.
