UAE | Traffic and Transport

Dubai Metro allows food parcels

Commuters can't be penalised unless they are found eating on board.

  • By Ashfaq Ahmed, Chief Reporter
  • Published: 00:00 December 12, 2010
  • Gulf News

Metro commuters exit at Khalid Bin Al Waleed Station
  • Image Credit: Megan Hirons Mahon/Gulf News
  • Metro commuters exit at Khalid Bin Al Waleed Station. Thousands used the Metro for free on Monday.

Dubai: Inspectors — issuing fines and penalising commuters for carrying food parcels on the Dubai Metro — have gone overboard, commuters said.

In a recent incident, a passenger's food package was confiscated onboard the Metro, following which he was asked to disembark at the next station to pay the fine.

"The inspector told me it is not allowed to carry food parcels on board the train because they stink and cause nuisance to other passengers," the Metro user, who wished to remain anonymous, said.

He added that he had bought the food from a shopping mall to take home to his children.

"I wonder whether the Metro inspectors will also start issuing fines to commuters carrying their lunch boxes to work," another regular Metro user said, adding that the inspectors had never issued any warnings or showed leniency.

"It seems that they have some target to meet and issue fines for any minor mistakes," he said.

However, a senior official at the Roads and Transport Authority (RTA) said that it was wrong to issue fines unless a passenger was found consuming food on board the Metro.

"No fines are issued to passengers for carrying food parcels and if someone has been given such fines, he should contact the RTA customer service call centre to lodge a complaint and his fine will be reimbursed," Ramadan Abdullah, Director of Operations at the RTA's Rail Agency, said.

In another incident, an Arab businessman — who was visiting Dubai for investment purposes — said that he had been fined for eating a piece of candy, during a recent Metro trip.

Humiliated

"I am a visitor and took the train just for pleasure. I did not know that a passenger can be fined only for having a candy..." he said in a letter to Gulf News.

He added that he was escorted out of the train by two policemen when he protested against the fine.

"They should show some respect to visitors as I felt insulted," he said.

On this particular issue, Abdullah said: "Rule is the same for every one whether a passenger is a visitor or resident. It is clearly mentioned on the station and the trains that eating and drinking is not allowed on board the trains."

Other passengers said they had been fined for chewing gum on board.

As per the list of fines stipulated in the Order number 3/2009 governing the Unified Fare of Mass Transport in the Emirate of Dubai, a fine could be as minimal as Dh100 — for eating and drinking in the trains and the prohibited areas on stations and bus stops — or as high as Dh500 for offences such as destroying, damaging or tampering with devices, equipment or seats of public transport facilities and services. Resting one's feet on the seats is also subject to a fine.

Chewing gum was prohibited because passengers either spit it on the floor or stick it on the seats.

"We cannot allow passengers to damage the mass transport and its facilities including buses, trains, stations and other services," Abdullah said.

These rules are applicable on all modes of public transport including the Metro, public and the water buses. As per law, carrying alcoholic beverages inside the stations or the trains is an offence too, while spitting, littering or any other act which defaces trains or stations is also be subject to fines.

Additionally, passengers found harassing passengers or causing an inconvenience or disturbance to other users could be penalised too.

Are you are regular Metro user? Have you been fined for carrying food on the Metro? How is your overall experience of using the service?

Comments (20)

  1. Added 18:13 December 12, 2010

    I am an occasional metro user. I usually board on Union MS to end my journey at Ibn Batuta MS. I travel along with my children ( 3yrs & 5yrs),and the duration of journey is 50mints. If waiting period at MS for train to arrive and the journey period is totaled ,it comes around an hour plus.My kids keep on asking for water during the journey in peak summers,and I have to abide by the Metro rules,which even does not let to quench the thirst of children. Bizarreness!!!

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  2. Added 17:38 December 12, 2010

    This is not a question of fines, Dubai government wants to keep the city clean So, we can say "WOW" what a very beautiful city dubai is. I feel very happy to enter any public transport becuase its beautiful.

    vivek, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  3. Added 17:03 December 12, 2010

    I am now a regular with the metro since 2 weeks. I can totally understand fining for chewing gums as people can leave on or under seats etc or consuming on the train. But fining people for food parcels or for their lunch box is insane and Yes this needs to be communicated well to both the inspectors as well as the public to ensure clean and healthy surroundings.

    Savitha V, Sharjah, United Arab Emirates

  4. Added 15:32 December 12, 2010

    I think they should ban people with bad body odor.

    Jintu, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  5. Added 14:55 December 12, 2010

    this is a bit too strict, agreed metro and other mass transport means have to be maintained and taken care of, but that doesnt imply one has to follow such rules, we being commuters have the duty to maintain and and take care of the transport facilities provided, but at the same time some leniency, warnings have to be given to those found doing anything that is not allowed. Hence after all it is for the convenience of the average person that we have such facilities provided not for making his travelling an uncomfortable experience

    Anonymous, dubai, United Arab Emirates

  6. Added 12:46 December 12, 2010

    Its their responsibility to educate the people regarding thier rules and regulations. It would be better to give them warning if they violated for the first time. Based on my experience I paid 100 dirhams as a penalty for checking inside the Gold Member cabin where I did'nt know that an ordinary NOL card holder like me is not allowed to use it. I tried to explain but they insisted that I disobey the rule. I cant do anything but to pay even its against my will. Hope that the inspector understand the situation not just implement the policy... :(

    Anonymous, Ajman, United Arab Emirates

  7. Added 12:40 December 12, 2010

    I am a regular metro user & I do not blame the authorities for fining people for consuming food and beverages, but they should be reasonable in doing so. Imagine people walking to the metro in the summer and would not be able to drink water. The metro stations can have a designated area where people are allowed to consume food and beverages in an emergency. But overall I support the idea that the mass transport system should remain clean & healthy for all commuters.

    Franklin, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  8. Added 12:36 December 12, 2010

    We should follow rules and regulations to keep us away from troubles and inconveniences and in order for us to follow we should have self-discipline.

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  9. Added 12:05 December 12, 2010

    I have a friend who collapsed in the metro and broke his collar bone. Reason, he was diabetic patient and respected the rules. Any thoughts?

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  10. Added 12:04 December 12, 2010

    It good that they dont allow food consumption on board the Metro ... but they r going a little over-board. Too many restictions will only cause inconvinience ...

    Swetha Krishnan, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  11. View more comments

Crackdown

Passports seized in Dish TV crackdown

Dubai airport

Swords, knives, fake guns seized in Dubai

India-Pakistan

New visa rules thrill cross-border couples

Community Reports

More from Community Reports

Video

In the lanes of Deira Spice Souq

Gallery

A pick of the best pictures taken by readers