UAE | Health

Strict TB check needed to keep disease away

UAE health officials justify screening procedures

  • By Dina El Shammaa, Abu Dhabi Deputy Editor
  • Published: 00:00 July 13, 2011
  • Gulf News

TB scars mainly arise when the outer layer of the lung has been infected in the past
  • Image Credit: Supplied
  • TB scars mainly arise when the outer layer of the lung has been infected in the past and not necessarily by TB.

Abu Dhabi: People with old tuberculosis (TB) scar are scientifically symptom free, however the condition can be easily reactivated if the person's immunity system is reduced for any reason, stressed senior health officials. For that reason, newcomers to the UAE with an old TB scar are denied a residency visa, and are no longer allowed to enter the country.

Dr Kalthoom Hassan, director of national TB programme and director of specialised health care at the UAE Ministry of Health (MoH), told Gulf News that the health ministry is currently looking into introducing a TB filtration programme, which ensures that new-comers arriving from countries with high TB prevalence are screened in their home towns before entering UAE ports.

"We realise that it's inhumane to separate families, and sympathise with those found to have scars in the outer layer of their lung; however we are doing this because an old scar TB can be easily activated if a person's immunity system is reduced for any reason.

Stricter rules

"That's why the MoH is implementing even stricter TB rules and is now revising TB regulations, to ensure newcomers arriving from high-risk TB prevalent countries are screened in their hometowns first," clarified Dr Kalthoom.

Scar TB becomes active once a person's immunity system is reduced, and this is commonly found among the elderly and children under the age of five.

"People with old TB scars are carriers, which still poses a threat to society, and this can only be detected through a chest X-ray, which is an inexpensive, accurate and quick method practised globally," said Dr Kalthoom.

Close contacts to an old TB carrier is also considered a threat, and is sent back to their country once treated and become non-infectious.

When asked whether countries such as the US and the UK are as strict with their newcomers regarding old scar TB, Dr Kalthoom said: "There's a global intention to reduce the spread of TB and introduce early diagnosis, treatment and follow up. Both the UK and the US require that immigrants from countries with high TB incidence have a chest X-ray on arrival. However I believe that they are revisiting their current TB regulations in order to implement stricter rules."

The Division of Tuberculosis Elimination, US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention, state that "current British border policies require immigrants from countries with a TB incidence higher than 40 per 100,000 people to have a chest X-ray on arrival to check for active TB."

CDC reports show that in the US, "any applicant for whom the clinical suspicion of tuberculosis is high enough to warrant treatment for tuberculosis disease, regardless of laboratory results is considered Class A, which requires screening follow-up mandated by US immigration law."

Concern

A concern was raised as a response to a previous Gulf News article on TB. Dr Farida Al Hosani, Section Head of Communicable Diseases at the Health Authority Abu Dhabi (HAAD), questioned the articles headline "chest X-ray to check for fitness is outdated" describing it as "misleading"

"X-ray is the first line of screening for TB worldwide and there's no other screening test recommended until today. This is according to HAAD standards, CDC guidelines for screening of immigrants and many other guidelines."

A risk to community

The Health Authority Abu Dhabi, Dubai Health Authority and the MoH are currently discussing and revising the current TB control programme.

In a 2010 HAAD study which summarises the risk of TB among 948,504 residents in Abu Dhabi — 14 per cent out of the 1,558 people who had TB were found to have IGRA positive (which means that there is latent TB that might reactivate any time) — 9 per cent were found to have TST (Tuberculin Skin Test Positive). "These results may cause a risk to the community that we have to consider and plan for," said Dr Farida Al Hosani, Section Head of Communicable Diseases at HAAD.

Comments (10)

  1. Added 12:58 July 13, 2011

    I am working in UAE since past 10 years and would be going for a change in job. My concern is, will i have to undergo the same rigorous criteria for fitness as in the case of new expatriaes? If i had developed PTB recently, which i suspect, what would be my fate? What would happen if i had taken a loan from bank.

    Dinesh, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  2. Added 12:40 July 13, 2011

    this is unfair! everybody knows that there are lot of people who always visit and work here in uae, even some uae nationals also having this kind of desease. I hope they have to regulate this to those person who have positive TB, not those who already pass or already cured. As per doctors and specialist, the people who got this kind of disease and cured already, but have scars are already treated, so no risk. this is inactived desease. Many peoples lives will be affected by this, i hope our the authorities think it first very well the said implementation. They must exclude those who have scars only, because they are capable to work too and give them opportunity. Not to put them down in their life.

    Anonymous, fujairah, United Arab Emirates

  3. Added 12:13 July 13, 2011

    this is inhuman......I think the authorities should do the Bronchioscopy at the cost of candidate before declaring him unfit. If Bronchioscopy test is negative then they should declare the candidate as fit for employment.

    Praveen, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  4. Added 12:08 July 13, 2011

    Hopefully authorities would consider revision of the rules to allow those who have suffered from the disease and were healed to live and have another chance in the society without being discriminated... let anybody know about a TB scar and see the reaction... hopefully stereotypes would change their outlook to these people...

    Anonymous, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

  5. Added 12:03 July 13, 2011

    Since the law is for new comers......what is the rule for existing people working in UAE if they want to change their job?? (I have a scar in my chest for which they have done Sputum test which was negative) whether they will do the same test & issue fitness certificate?

    Paul Smith, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  6. Added 11:27 July 13, 2011

    I completely agree with this movement. I know that many do not. However, I do not prefer to intermix with people who have such dangerous diseases as TB. When my child goes to school, I certainly do not want him socializing with children with these conditions as well. It is harsh but safer for the people who do not have such conditions. Good work MOH and HAAD!!!

    Anonymous, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

  7. Added 11:17 July 13, 2011

    It is a well known fact that human body with a failing immune system would be prone to act as host to various infections/ diseases. So a scar left behind need not be the only reason for the person to contract TB. He could have contracted the same even without a past history of PTB, since he already has his immune system down. The million dollar question is: How to deal with a situation wherein expatriates who have been working for many years have been found with notable indications in X Ray during their visa renewal or job change. Any answers???

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  8. Added 10:12 July 13, 2011

    This news is really sad and inhuman. Why are people who had TB in past are being punished? Everyone knows there are lot of people who come from different countries to live and make a good life here and issues like these really harm ones feelings, especially when people are separated from families. I recently got married and when i applied for residency visa for my wife it was denied due to this issue. Only Allah can answer to our prayers now and give us a solution.

    Mohammad Matheen, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  9. Added 09:56 July 13, 2011

    It's totally wrong...My wife got a scar and she was rejected residency visa then I told to doctor that it's old scar, can't be activated. They took her test for 3 consective days and finally passed her...So, as her visa is going to expire again. Will they allow her to stay then or not?

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  10. Added 09:31 July 13, 2011

    Its totally Inhuman. Is it applicable only for new commers , or its applicable for for those who are changing there residence visa?

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Gulf News

Crackdown

Passports seized in Dish TV crackdown

Dubai airport

Swords, knives, fake guns seized in Dubai

India-Pakistan

New visa rules thrill cross-border couples

Community Reports

More from Community Reports

Gallery

A pick of the best pictures taken by readers

Video

In the lanes of Deira Spice Souq