UAE | Health

Scientist challenges cholesterol treatment

Alleges pharmaceutical industry has lowered safe levels

  • By Mahmood Saberi, Senior Reporter
  • Published: 00:00 March 13, 2011
  • Gulf News

Dr George Birkmayer
  • Image Credit: Supplied
  • Dr George Birkmayer

Dubai: A German medical scientist has alleged that pharmaceutical companies are striking fear into people about safe cholesterol levels and making money at the cost of the health of people.

Dr George Birkmayer, a professor of medical chemistry, says that long-term use of cholesterol reducing drugs (statins) causes cancer and also affects a person's sex life. "Nobody tells you that. It's confidential [about the cancer effect]," he said.

The scientist claims he has succeeded in stabilising a substance found naturally in the human body and using it to boost energy levels. The co-enzyme is called NADH and is a biological form of hydrogen. It reacts with the oxygen in every living cell and produces energy, he says.

He warned that when cholesterol levels are lowered with the aid of drugs, the cell membrane becomes unstable and, over a period of time, causes cancer. It also tends to lower the level of sex hormones, he said. Men who find that they are impotent often become depressed and then have to take anti-depressants.

An internal medicine specialist earlier told Gulf News that using cholesterol drugs reduces one's libido. "But you have to weigh the risks [of not taking statins]."

Cholesterol is a wax-like substance in the body that is used for producing vitamin D and bile acids to digest fat. If there is too much cholesterol in the blood, it gets deposited in arteries that supply blood to the heart, brain and legs. The arteries become narrow and the blood supply is blocked.

Dr Birkmayer alleges that pharma companies pay for luxurious vacations to professors to come to a consensus statement on the safe level of cholesterol. "It's all manipulated. Nobody is thinking about prevention, which is the cheapest and best form of treatment," he said.

Marketing trick alleged

He said pharmaceutical companies had hit on a brilliant marketing idea. When he managed a medical laboratory in Austria some 30 years ago, the upper normal range of cholesterol used to be 300 (mg/dl), he said. "That meant only five per cent of the population had elevated levels."

He alleges that the industry decided on less than 200 mg/dl as a safe level, which meant that 60 per cent of the population was left with an elevated level.

Dr Birkmayer said simple lifestyle changes like diet changes could bring cholesterol levels to a normal range. He said NADH lowers cholesterol without the side-effects and has been proven by a study performed at Georgetown University in Washington DC. He added that the co-enzyme was also found to prevent diabetes.

The professor has teamed up with Peter Backwinkel, a biophysical medicine therapist to open the first Biophysical Medicine Institute at Dubai HealthCare City.

The therapist said the Institute will soon conduct the clinical trials only after approval by the Centre for Healthcare Planning and Quality (CPQ) to test the efficacy of their unique method of treatment. The treatment called the Biofield test involves eliminating the body's chronic stress factors and improving energy.

Dr Birkmayer said more than 25 patients who were taking NADH earlier found their blood sugar level dropped after three months and have remained stable for the past three years.

The scientist said the medications available for diabetes did not represent a cure. "They are a stabilisation process." He said that over the years the situation gets worse and worse, and finally a patient is forced to take insulin or have dialysis. "The cost will explode. Over the long-term it is a real threat," he said.

He said people who are over-weight and show the first symptoms of diabetes like a feeling of acute thirst and the need to drink water, should seek treatment. He claimed the treatment at such a stage would prevent diabetes.

Blackwinkel said the mortality rate of those who get diabetes before 30 years of age is 20 years earlier then others. "Diabetes has a dramatic impact on the quality of life." He said if the present diabetes trend continues in Germany, the health system will collapse within the next 20 years. One in four people in the UAE suffer from diabetes and the Emirates has the second-highest rate of the disease in the world.

Comments (6)

  1. Added 03:09 March 14, 2011

    I have researched cholesterol and cholesterol lowering drugs for the past 3 years and cannot understand why everyone is fooled by the techniques the big pharma companies use. They use relative statistics to achieve a 30-50% supposed benefit. whereas the benefit is 1% or less. They just tell everyone the relative statistics not the absolute statistics. But the side effects are up in the 20-30%. That is 30 out of 100 will have side effects, many of which can be devastating.

    Dr Peter Dingle, Perth, Australia

  2. Added 22:25 March 13, 2011

    Herein lies the facts and nothing but the facts. This is a great article! I haven't tried NADH for this purpose but there are also many other non-liver-damaging nutrients that reduce cholesterol by reducing inflammation and normalizing the hormones produced by cholesterol.

    Tony D, Stuart, FL, United States

  3. Added 20:51 March 13, 2011

    I read about the dangers of using statins some years ago. I'm glad that a medical doctor is confirming the earlier views of a lay person.

    Sethu Kumar, Dubai, Afghanistan

  4. Added 16:05 March 13, 2011

    30 years ago, the rule-of-thumb for a healthy cholesterol level was 200+age. At that time, the best medication to alter lipid levels in the blood was niacin. Then in the early 1990's, the first statins started to gain acceptance as a treatment. Statins primarily affect LDL cholesterol but have little effect on HDL or triglycerides. Since the pharmaceutical companies fund almost all research in the U.S., they setup "studies" showing how statins lowered LDL and decreased heart disease. As a result, the "healthy" range for normal cholesterol began to drop. At the same time. treatment for heart attack patients improved so deaths from heart disease dropped too. Small problem though. The pharmaceutical companies studies that showed no benefit from statins were never published. Side effects from the drugs and from the lower cholesterol levels were [allegedly] buried and hidden. Data from the World Health Organization's study with data form 164 countries showed that overall mortality was lowest at a total cholesterol level between 200 and 240. As total cholesterol dropped to 150, death from any cause increased four-fold. Lower is not better.

    Ed Terry, Kensington, MD, United States

  5. Added 13:20 March 13, 2011

    Nice article , very surprised to know our medical field has become so business oriented .

    justin, dubai, United Arab Emirates

  6. Added 10:15 March 13, 2011

    I agree with the doctor, I too had a major scare a couple of years back when I was diagnosed with high cholesterol levels & sugar too. I was prescribed medication, which I did not take. However, with change in lifestyle and caution I managed to reduce all the dangerous markers. Of course Ramadan was put the meaning of control on fast track. In 3 to 6 months everything was normal. Also after going through all the scare mongering by the family, I am cautious at all these company provided buffets. & voila ... self control is the best solution.

    Mustafa Shabbir, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

Gulf News

Crackdown

Passports seized in Dish TV crackdown

Dubai airport

Swords, knives, fake guns seized in Dubai

India-Pakistan

New visa rules thrill cross-border couples

Community Reports

More from Community Reports

Gallery

A pick of the best pictures taken by readers

Video

In the lanes of Deira Spice Souq