Business | Property

Investors irate over stalled Emaar development

Investors in Emaar's 29 Boulevard Towers are furious as the project shows no progress

  • By Jay B. Hilotin, Chief Reporter
  • Published: 00:00 April 1, 2010
  • XPRESS

  • Image Credit: Xpress/Jay B. Hilotin
  • Concrete and rusted metal bars is all that riled investors find at the construction site of the 29 Boulevard towers

Dubai: Jobless architect Sanjay K. looks up at motionless cranes over an abandoned construction site. His gaze falls upon a mesh of metal bars now brown with rust. He had invested all his savings in a one-bedroom unit in this project with borrowed money, for which he may face imprisonment.

Sanjay (not his real name) and several other investors last week showed to XPRESS the building site of 29 Boulevard Towers in Dubai's Old Town. The project, designed by US-based Frank Williams, is owned by developer Emaar Properties.

"It was greed that led all of us into this situation," said Sanjay, who requested that his name be changed because he has banks chasing him for loan payments.

Lost hopes

Sanjay spent Dh550,000 of his own money, plus a personal loan of Dh150,000 to pay 16 per cent of the price of the 740-square-foot unit he bought at Dh3.15 million at 29 Boulevard, nearly triple the prevailing market price today.

"I gave Emaar everything I had. Thankfully, my wife still has a job and is paying Dh10,000 as interest on the mortgage for this non-existent property. My plan was to sell it at a profit. Then the crash happened," said Sanjay, who was made redundant in January 2009, four months after he got hooked by the five per cent price reduction from Emaar when he bought the unit in August 2008. His story is on Facebook and Google.

Italian property executive Sylvia Turrin bought a two-bedroom unit in the same project off-plan three years ago. She also sold units from the same project to other Italian investors, many of whom have paid over 65 per cent of the unit price. "Three years have passed since its launch and it's still at the foundation stage. The work progress is less than 60 per cent.

"For people like me who invested in this project, it will be impossible to wait another three years," said Turrin.

Daily increase

Another investor, who paid Dh685,000 to Emaar for a 29 Boulevard unit, said: "I wanted to live in it or rent it. Emaar increased the price on a daily basis. In our group, we have people who have paid from Dh1,200 per square foot to Dh4,000 per square foot for the same type of apartment in the same building."

A senior Emaar official met some investors last week and had promised to answer their queries in a meeting on Wednesday. However, this meeting was cancelled.

"Let us withdraw from the ownership of this property as I don't believe they want to build this structure," said Sanjay.

The plan

29 Boulevard, Old Town, consists of two high-rise towers of 44 and 45 storeys with podium-level amenities and podium car parking.

Dubai Law No 8 of 2007 ("Escrow Law") came into effect on 28 June 2007.

The law guarantees buyers of units in "off-plan" developments that the payment instalments they were making to the developer were being used to construct the development.

The Real Estate Regulatory Agency (Rera), formed by Law No 14 of 2007 and which comes under the umbrella of the Dubai Land Department, has been given the responsibility of, among other matters, implementing the escrow regulations.

Comments (17)

  1. Added 12:18 April 4, 2010

    Emaar, since the beginning, has been on the top of the pyramid in terms of investor confidence, timely delivery and high standards of construction and that is why most of the investors have put in their money with Emaar without asking any questions. Emaar should either complete the property and compensate the investors for late delivery or refund the money collected from investors along with interest.

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  2. Added 23:07 April 3, 2010

    My advice to people who have invested in Downtown Burj area is not to fret too much about it. Good quality properties in prime localities cannot go wrong in the long run. Investors in other areas with unknown developers are the ones who should really worry. I hold properties in Downtown where the rent I receive does not meet my mortgage payments however I know I will be able to make something out of it in a few years time. At the moment it’s only about survival.

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  3. Added 22:40 April 3, 2010

    It’s good that you’re highlighting this because a lot of people have suffered and are continuing to suffer. Emaar is the same as all the others and as one of the comments says their staff are impolite and unhelpful. Emaar made a dishonourable promise that whoever bought an Emaar property would automatically be entitled to a three-year residence visa. Now not only is a three-year residence visa not available but the substitute of a six month visa is simply a multi-purpose visit visa only for the property owner and not for the family. This is no way to build confidence in Dubai as investors’ rights need to be guaranteed as well. Will anyone listen?

    Kaif, London, United Kingdom

  4. Added 21:36 April 3, 2010

    Due to this crash in the real estate sector, several other businesses also got affected and this has resulted in most of us facing jail time for no fault from our side. I sincerely appeal to the authorities of this great country to think of a solution to safeguard the interest of the innocents who have invested in this country to be a part of this great nation and grow with this nation. I hope someone comes up with a serious response to my appeal.

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  5. Added 20:40 April 3, 2010

    Hope the situation will improve shortly. But I think it would be difficult to retain demand for high-value properties.

    Dastagir Abdulsalam, Trichur, India

  6. Added 18:14 April 3, 2010

    It’s better to put your money in a bank and make some nice interest. Don’t pay if you can’t see any concrete structure before your eyes. Treat this as a lesson.

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  7. Added 18:07 April 3, 2010

    Anybody following the Onyx Project on Shaikh Zayed Road...a development next to the Emaar office? I have paid 50 per cent of the sale price and the progress of this project is at best 10 per cent in the last three years. What happens to my investment where the developer is clearly late and holds 50 per cent of my money?

    Shahbaz Hussain, Sharjah, United Arab Emirates

  8. Added 16:54 April 3, 2010

    The customer care is unaware of the project status; the senior management makes false promises to resolve issues. Appointment with senior management is hard to get and, if given, it is cancelled on a short notice. A law should be introduced to give comfort to investors and end-users, and permit investors to cancel their contract and get back their hard earned money invested in this project.

    Investor of 29 blvd, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  9. Added 15:01 April 3, 2010

    I invested with Almasah International Real Estate for a property in Jumeirah Village. The completion date according to the contract was in the second quarter 2009, but there is nothing going on till this date. I always keep calling them and asking about the construction but they always say: “The manager is out, please live your mobile number and we’ll call you back.” But they never call back. Now, because of delayed delivery, they must pay me nine per cent of the total amount I paid, but they have told me to wait till completion, and I don't know what to do

    Anonymous, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  10. Added 14:46 April 3, 2010

    If you think this is bad, what about people like me who bought a two-bedroom flat from ETA star (Verde project) for Dh8.5million? It’s been three years and they are sitting on our 10 per cent with nothing to show for it but a hole in the ground. Greed led most of us to this point and we now have no option to get our money back.

    Adel, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  11. View more comments

Douglas Okasaki

Blog: Connection

Douglas Okasaki writes about media and more

Business Editor's choice