Airbus, Boeing claim victoryin WTO ruling

Decision covers subsidies, market shares

Last updated:

Geneva: European aircraft maker Airbus received state subsidies that hurt US rival Boeing, but not all of them were illegal under international rules, the World Trade Organisation (WTO) said.

Wednesday's mixed verdict by a WTO appeal panel partly reversed an earlier ruling by the global trade body, but still allowed both Brussels and Washington to claim a victory of sorts in their seven-year tit-for-tat dispute over financial aid to airplane manufacturers.

EU Trade Commissioner Karel De Gucht described the latest ruling as an "important result," particularly because the panel concluded that billions in research and development grants for the Airbus A380 superjumbo weren't illegal.

"The US claim that Airbus received prohibited export subsidies has been dismissed in its entirety," the European Union trade chief said. "In addition, a number of claims relating to R&D and infrastructure among others were either rejected or only partially accepted."

His counterpart in Washington, US Trade Representative Ron Kirk, said the panel's ruling still meant Airbus had received $18 billion in illegal state support over four decades.

"These subsidies have greatly harmed the United States, including causing Boeing to lose sales and market share in key markets throughout the world," Kirk said. "Launch aid is illegal, and the European Union and the member states should refrain from future launch aid disbursements."

The panel overturned an earlier finding that US rival Boeing had lost market share in Brazil, Mexico, Singapore and Taiwan because of the subsidies. But it upheld a June ruling that European subsidies to Airbus had caused Boeing to lose market share elsewhere, particularly in Asia.

The panel also concluded that financial aid provided by France, Germany, Spain and Britain for the development of many Airbus planes "caused serious prejudice to the interests of the United States."

The European Union will now be given several months to rectify those practices the WTO found to be illegal, after which Washington can approach the global body with any request for damages. These would be paid in the form of punitive tariffs on European goods, but it is far from certain that the WTO will grant such measures.

The politically charged dispute over a market for commercial passenger aircraft believed to be worth more than $3 trillion over the next two decades has led both sides, at times, to claim victory regardless of the latest development.

Airbus chief executive Tom Enders expressed satisfaction Wednesday at the appeal panel's verdict. "This is a big win for Europe," he said.

Boeing Chairman Jim McNerney said the ruling is "a clear, final win for fair trade that will level the playing field for America's aerospace workers." In Washington, US Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus said, "This ruling cracks down on illegal trade subsidies that cost American jobs and helps ensure a global economy where US workers can compete and win."

Another complaint

A separate complaint lodged by Brussels over what it says are illegal US subsidies to Boeing is working its way through the trade court.

In March, the WTO ruled that Boeing received at least $5 billion in subsidies between 1989 and 2006 that were prohibited under international trade rules.

An appeal panel is expected to rule on that case in the coming months.

Get Updates on Topics You Choose

By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Up Next