World | Philippines

Bodies, survivors of Manila hijack drama head home

Most survivors of deadly hostage drama in Manila return home to Hong Kong, along with bodies of tourists killed in the incident

  • AP
  • Published: 09:00 August 25, 2010

Philippine hostage crisis probe
  • Image Credit: AFP
  • A Philippine forensic expert looks for evidence inside the tourist bus which was hijacked by an ex-policeman and subsequently stormed by police in Manila on August 24, 2010, a day after the bloody assault. Philippine police conceded they made blunders in ending the bus hijacking as outrage grew over the bloody assault played out on live television that left eight Hong Kong tourists dead.
Image 1 of 5
12345

Manila: Most survivors of a tragic hostage drama were returning home to Hong Kong along with the bodies of eight slain tourists on Wednesday, while the Philippines grappled with outrage over police mishandling and botched negotiations with the gunman.

The interior secretary acknowledged that police were ill-prepared and that a series of lapses might have instigated bloodshed on Monday when the hostage-taker, a disgruntled former policeman demanding his job back, killed eight bus passengers and shot others before a police sniper killed him.

Nine other passengers had been released hours earlier and seven were rescued from the bullet-riddled bus, three of them is serious condition.

One of the wounded will remain in intensive care in Manila, and another will be brought back on a medivac plane, said Hong Kong Undersecretary for Security T.K. Lai.

The rest were to fly aboard a chartered plane to Hong Kong later on Wednesday after a Buddhist ceremony and a send-off by military officers at the Manila airport, said Philippine Welfare Secretary Dinky Soliman.

Workers at a funeral parlor loaded the coffins into wooden boxes for the flight home. They left for the airport in a caravan of hearses led by a police car. A small group of about 10 people, hands clasped in front of their chests, hummed a Buddhist chant.

President Benigno Aquino III, facing his first major crisis since taking office on June 30, declared on Wednesday a national day of mourning in solidarity with the people of Hong Kong. Flags were lowered at government offices and embassies.

A consternated China demanded a full investigation. The Chinese ambassador visited Aquino on Tuesday, and the president talked on the phone with Hong Kong leader Donald Tsang.

Philippine Interior Secretary Jessie Robredo, who is in charge of the national police, acknowledged there were problems with how the crisis was handled.

"Had we been better prepared, better equipped, better trained, maybe the response would have been quicker despite the difficulty," Robredo told The Associated Press.

He added, "All the inadequacies happened at the same time."

Manila police chief Rodolfo Magtibay offered to go on leave while the investigation was ongoing. The assault firearms used by police commandos will be subjected to ballistic tests to determine if some of the hostages were hit by police gunfire, officials said.

Authorities were criticised for failing to prevent the brother of hostage-taker Roland Mendoza, who is also a policeman, from intervening in the negotiations.

Police officials said the brother urged Mendoza not to continue the talks unless authorities return his firearm, which was confiscated from him during the standoff.

Gregorio Menzona then threw a tantrum in front of TV cameras, which were broadcasting the daylong drama live, apparently prompting his brother to start shooting.

Filipino driver Alberto Lubang, who said he escaped as Mendoza opened fire, said the gunman was watching his brother resisting being handcuffed and loaded into a police car on TV inside the hijacked bus.

Aquino on Monday also criticised TV coverage, saying that footage of Mendoza's brother being taken into custody "might have further agitated the hostage-taker."

A heartbreaking picture emerged of the victims: a mother of three who lost her husband and two daughters, an injured teenager oblivious of her parents' deaths and a tour guide who aspired to become a yoga teacher.

Britain's Foreign Office said that two of the hostages who were released were British nationals. Three of the fatalities were Canadian, Philippine police said.

Survivor Amy Ng mourned the deaths of her husband Ken Leung, whom she said confronted the gunman, and daughters Doris and Jessie, aged 21 and 14. Her son, Jason, was wounded in the head and she will stay in Manila with him until he is fit to fly back.

"I thought I would fight for survival so I could take care of my children, but two of them have already died," a sobbing Ng said on Tuesday.

A bedridden, catatonic Tracey Wong told Hong Kong reporters she hid under a seat on the bus while Mendoza fired at the hostages.

"I want to find daddy and mommy quickly and see if they are OK," the 15-year-old said. But Hong Kong's radio RTHK reported that both her parents were among those killed, identifying her father as 51-year-old Wong Tze-lam.

Tour operator Hong Thai Travel Services general manager Susanna Lau praised a slain tour guide, 31-year-old Masa Tse, for his vigilance and decade-long service.

TV footage showed him peeking out of the bus during his captivity and later with one hand handcuffed to a position near the bus door.

Comments (18)

  1. Added 14:11 August 25, 2010

    There was lot could have been done , as we have seen on media that the hostage taker was calm and had shown lot of goodwill gestures by releasing women, childrens and olds . It was complete failure of Police in handling this crucial situation without ony professional acumen. Ultimately it turned violent because of communication gap and instigating the hostage taker by sending untrained cops .

    Nehal, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

  2. Added 12:14 August 25, 2010

    I do not understand what stupidity made philippines goverment not to accept the demands of the policemen . His demand is he wanted his job back and case to be waived off . At that time they could have accepted and released the hostages and later they would have arrested him . Very simple . The total responibility of loosing tourists lies on the goverment. The police official handled the case immeturely and foolishly. I saw the vedio in TV . Its poor handling and recklessness . They do not bother about the inmates of the Bus . The police they wanted to do their job rather than saving the inmates. Some i feel very bad about this.

    Anonymous, Dubai, Afghanistan

  3. Added 12:07 August 25, 2010

    This incident was a great disgrace to our country. Our government needs to apologize to the Hong Kong government as well as to the families of the victims. We can't blame other countries if they'll put as in their travel advisory as black listed. Our government should now think of a better solution on how to handle this sensitive situation.

    Candy Madia, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

  4. Added 12:05 August 25, 2010

    My deepest condolence to the families of the innocent citizens involved in this tragic incident. President Aquino look up, think and have a second thought. You can not just sit there and trust you men. Relieved the ground commander of the Manila SWAT team from post, he dont know anything. All personnel involved were to be relieved also from SWAT team and instead be just a traffic enforcer. Maybe with traffic enforcing job they can master traffic rules and regulations. The way the SWAT team handled the situation is totally unacceptable and shameful. PLEASE EDUCATE, TRAIN and EQUIP.

    JUAN TAMAD, dubai, United Arab Emirates

  5. Added 11:48 August 25, 2010

    They have plenty of time to negotiate. It would not have ended that way if they let a family member talk to him because he will surely listen to someone he love and would not have hardened his heart. His demand was very simple, yet there was no proper way of handling it. They could have convinced him that he will get his demands and once they have gotten him then thats the time to do proper invistigation and dealing with his case and demands.

    Anonymous, Sharjah, United Arab Emirates

  6. Added 10:32 August 25, 2010

    I symphatized for those who lost their loved ones from this event. There are a lot of cases in my country that had been unsolved or reversed because of political issues. In my own opinion, lack of knowledge among the police force on how to handle such cases lead to this hostage chaos. I beg to further investigate about the killings. Mr. Mendoza was the hostage taker, but in my understanding, some police had shot some of the victims too? Though most of the times, justice is not served well, I still hope it will prevail in some cases such as this.

    Anonymous, Ajman, United Arab Emirates

  7. Added 10:23 August 25, 2010

    the media have a great factor on why this hostage negotiation failed...

    Anonymous, al ain, United Arab Emirates

  8. Added 10:20 August 25, 2010

    This tragic end should have been avoided if there was media blackout. Obviously, the hostage-taker would not have shot the victims if he didn't see on tv what was being done to his brother. Responsible journalism, media ethics and professionalism should be observed on such sensitive cases.

    Anonymous, Abu Dhabi, Afghanistan

  9. Added 10:12 August 25, 2010

    As l had notice philippine policeman had no enough training and knowledge on handling hostage taking situation, they only know how to corupt only that, and most of the official are also corupt, only one hostage taking they dont know how to handle, there so many innocent people die because of the Government negligence. wake up Pilipino official, dont just sit and watch. this a very simple problem of a Policeman serving for a long time in your goverment.

    Anonymous, saba, Malaysia

  10. Added 09:48 August 25, 2010

    I was angered too on how the authorities mishandled the situation and how such demand was not given an immediate consideration knowing people's lives are at stake. We cannot surely get back the lives of the victims nor blame several people but hope this incident will served as a lesson to Philippine Government knowing this is not the very first hostage drama that happened in the country. Media as well must be aware of their role, it's not just giving the most recent update but taking consideration of the situation they are covering is a must too.

    Zoe, Davao City, Philippines

  11. View more comments

News Editor's choice