Defence faces questions in right to wear niqab

Judges seek way to respect religious freedom

Last updated:

Dubai: Seven judges of Canada's Supreme Court asked pointed questions of the lawyer representing a woman who wants to wear a niqab while facing her accused in a controversial sitting in Ottawa on Thursday.

While the court will take up to six months before issuing its decision, the nature of the questions suggested several high court judges believe wearing the niqab during a trial may compromise the right to a fair trial.

Judges, lawyers and juries have long used changes in facial expressions to gauge a witness's credibility while testifying. A niqab covers the entire face, leaving only the eyes visible, making it difficult for lawyers and juries to read any nuances or changes in expression.

An Ontario woman identified only as N.S. says her Muslim faith dictates she wear her niqab in public, including during the trial of two men who allegedly sexually assaulted her. David Butt, lawyer for N.S., told the justices that denying his client's right to wear a niqab would amount to imposing a special religious penalty on Muslims.

"If she were a man, and if she wore a yarmulke, a turban, or a clerical collar, it would be a no-brainer," Butt said in his opening statement. He ran into a salvo of questions from the justices suggesting they did not agree. Justice Morris Fish joined others on the bench in suggesting there isn't a single defence lawyer who would agree to allowing a witness to testify against their client without their face being clearly visible. "Yes," countered Butt. "Blind lawyers that I know."

"How about seeing lawyers?" Fish replied.

Two men are accused of raping N.S. as a child. The high court is trying to chart a course for future cases to respect an individual's right to religious freedom.

— with inputs from agencies

Get Updates on Topics You Choose

By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Up Next