Mumbai: Critics of the ban on beef in Maharashtra on Tuesday said the restrictions would prevent members of India’s Muslim and Christian minorities — and other groups that have no such taboo around eating beef, including some low-caste Hindus — from accessing an important and affordable source of protein.

“It’s discriminatory,” said Samar Halankar, a senior journalist, prominent food writer, and author of A Married Man’s Guide to Creative Cookery. “It’s a basic freedom that I should be allowed to eat what I want as long as I don’t force it on anyone else’s plate.”

Halankar said beef had been typically cheaper than other meats such as chicken or mutton, and that the ban might put all meat out of reach of the poor. “It’s an important source of protein for those who do eat it, but now meat itself might become unaffordable,” he said.

Beef was on Tuesday banned in Maharashtra with presidential assent being accorded to the relevant legislation — two decades after the assembly had passed it during the former Shiv Sena-BJP government in the state.

Presidential assent was accorded to the Maharashtra Animal Prevention (Amendment Bill), 1995, which bans even the slaughter of bulls and bullocks, but will allow the slaughter of water buffaloes, considered to yield an inferior quality of beef.

The state had already banned cow slaughter under the Maharashtra Animal Prevention Act, 1976, barring bulls or bullocks, the culling of which was permitted with certain regulations.

Maharashtra’s law not only bans the slaughter of cows and sale of beef, but the possession of the meat, which is now to be formally considered as contraband. It also imposes the toughest punishment — of up to five years in prison — for violations.

“Thanks a lot Hon President Sir for the assent on Maharashtra Animal Preservation Bill. Our dream of ban on cow slaughter becomes a reality now,” a pleased Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis said in a tweet.

BJP MP Kirit Somaiya, who had led a delegation to President Pranab Mukherjee on the issue recently, termed the assent as “a historic step with cultural as well as economic implications for the state”.

He said the bill passed by the Maharashtra legislature in 1995 was forwarded for the president’s assent in 1996.

“Subsequent governments in the state failed to do the needful and get the Bill implemented. We had committed to do this in our manifesto and have fulfilled it,” Somaiya said.

Mumbai alone consumes around 90,000kg of beef daily, with around 25 per cent accounting for water buffalo meat, called carabeef, through 900 licensed and hundreds more illegal outlets.

However, all the culling and processing of around 450 large animals which are slaughtered daily is carried out only at the Deonar Abattoir, Asia’s largest in north-east Mumbai.

Since the past several weeks, beef traders in a majority of the state’s cities and towns have been on strike protesting against harassment by right-wing and Hindu groups, who are also demanding closure of Deonar Abattoir.

Beef traders apprehend that the new development will render several thousands unemployed and also hike the prices of mutton, chicken, fish and other meats, both in the retail markets and in restaurants and hotels.