Classifieds powered by Gulf News

Muslim Brotherhood uprising call raises concern

Analysts highlight danger of extremists exploiting tensions in Egypt

Gulf News

Cairo: A Muslim Brotherhood call for an uprising in response to what it termed a “massacre” of its supporters in the wake of the military’s removal of Islamist president Mohammad Mursi could mark a bloody new stage in the turmoil rocking Egypt, analysts warn.

At dawn on Monday, after days of deadly violence and rising tensions between the Islamists and those who had called for Mursi’s departure, the Brotherhood said security forces had killed dozens of its supporters during prayers outside an army headquarters in Cairo.

Afterwards, the Brotherhood’s political arm, the Freedom and Justice Party, called for “an uprising” against those trying to “steal their revolution with tanks”.

And the movement likened army chief Abdul Fattah Al Sisi, the general behind Mursi’s ouster, to Syrian President Bashar Al Assad, saying he wanted “to take Egypt in the same direction as Syria” and rule from behind the scenes.

“The Muslim Brotherhood are adopting a very dangerous attitude. They are insisting on escalating the situation,” said Hassan Nafaa, professor of political science at Cairo University.

He branded the Brotherhood leadership “extremists” and called on the moderate wing within the movement to pressure them into restraint.

“Emotions are very high, and there is real anger on the streets,” Nafaa warned.

Monday’s clashes marked the latest escalation in a wave of violence since Mursi’s ouster that has left scores dead nationwide, including at least 37 following Islamist rallies on Friday, and despite talk of peaceful protests.

Egyptian analyst Hesham Qasim highlighted the danger of extremists exploiting the tensions, including the former militant group Jamaa Islamiya and jihadists in the restive Sinai peninsula.

“There is a danger that some of them may resort to terror. If the army does not guarantee security, what is happening may make us wish for our dictators,” Qasim said, alluding to Hosni Mubarak, the autocrat overthrown in a popular uprising in February 2011.


Like others, Qasim argued that inflammatory language being used by the Islamists had stoked the unrest.

Residents of the normally quiet Cairo neighbourhood of Menial said a deadly attack on Friday began shortly after the Brotherhood’s supreme guide, Mohammad Badie, gave a fiery speech to Mursi supporters in Cairo’s Nasr City.

“They are attempting to reverse the situation by creating panic, by putting the situation out of proportion,” Qasim argued.

But he said there was currently no reason to fear the deteriorating security situation would drag Egypt in the same direction as Syria.

“Here we have a professional army that refused to fire on its people. When Mursi ordered them to rein in the country they refused.”

Another scenario that events in Egypt have prompted media references to is the one that arose in Algeria in the early 1992 when the army decided to cancel elections that an Islamic party was poised to win.

The decision sparked almost a decade of appalling bloodletting, with some 200,000 people killed in fighting that pitted Islamist insurgents against the military and took a particularly heavy toll on civilians.

“In Algeria it was a real dream [to elect an Islamist government]. It was a theoretical alternative. But in Egypt the Islamists stayed in power for one year and the people were suffering at the end of it,” said Egyptian political analyst Amr Al Shobaki.

He was referring to the widely held belief among the millions who marched last week calling for his ouster that Mursi failed to improve the lives of ordinary Egyptians during his year in power.

Mursi’s turbulent rule was marked by accusations that he failed the 2011 revolution by concentrating power in Islamist hands and letting the economy go into freefall.

But while discounting violence of the kind that devastated Algeria, Al Shobaki called some of the language used by the Brotherhood’s leaders “shocking”.

He warned that some of them were manipulating Islamist youths, which “could lead towards violence”.

“It is a danger,” he said.

In the immediate future there has been speculation that Ramadan, which starts on Wednesday, might help calm the situation by encouraging protesters to stay at home.

But analysts expressed doubt.

“The situation is so complicated right now that I don’t think it will make any difference,” said Qasim.