Why India's youth are abandoning their elderly parents

The statistics are shocking: one in every three senior citizens in India is a victim of abuse. Why are the elderly being left in the cold by their families in a land that reveres the old, asks Nilima Pathak and Anand Raj OK

  • Parvatiben has no one to look after her and lives in a shelter for elderly people in Gujarat. Image Credit: Supplied picture
  • Avikar who worked at a UK law firm, was abandoned by his family. Image Credit: Supplied picture
24 Friday

Seventy-five-year-old Kusum Lata* remembers the heart-wrenching afternoon that changed her life like it was yesterday. “I’d had my lunch of chappatis and dal and was resting in my room in Karol Bagh, central Delhi, when my son Amit* walked in and asked if I would like to visit our relative in Ghaziabad, in the neighbouring state of Uttar Pradesh, about an hour’s drive away.’’

She was excited at the prospect of going on a car ride with her only son. “I was looking forward to spending some time with him,’’ she says. The frail septuagenarian agreed to the journey, not knowing that it would be the last time she’d ever see her son and his family.

“Although I was trying to make conversation with him on the way, he appeared to be deep in thought and was silent,’’ she remembers.

After driving about 40 minutes, once they were on the highway, Amit, who is 50 and a father himself, stopped the car near a roadside fruit stall and asked her to step out to buy some apples. “As I was choosing the fruit, I saw my son start the vehicle, and before I could call out to him, he sped off,’’ says Kusum, a tear rolling down her deeply creased face.

“Initially I thought he’d gone to fill petrol or buy something, so I waited in the hot sun for several hours hoping he would return. But then, late in the evening, the truth dawned on me – I’d been abandoned by my own son; my only son and child.’’

Taking pity on the elderly woman sitting sobbing by the side of the road, a few local residents helped her to an old-age home run by a charity in Ghaziabad. Emotionally distraught, she was initially reluctant to provide details about her son to the volunteers, but after much prodding she finally revealed his address.

A month later, representatives of the charity tracked down Amit to ask him to take his mother home, but he refused, saying he was disowning her as she was a burden to care for.

A volunteer at the home that took Kusum in two years ago says, “A few months before getting rid of his mother, Amit reportedly made her transfer the ownership of her house to him.’’

‘They took all I had and dumped me’

The saving grace in Kusum’s case is that she was not physically abused, unlike Uma*, a thin, frail woman who lies on the cot next to Kusum’s in the Ghaziabad home. The 80-year-old woman’s hands and legs bear marks of bruises and cuts, a result of the abuse she suffered at the hands of some relatives. They tortured her, forcing her to give them all her gold jewellery worth around Rs90,000 (Dh6,128), before they dumped her in front of the old-age home one evening in May last year. “They didn’t want me so they took all that I had and dumped me here,’’ she says, her voice flat.

Kusum and Uma are just two of the millions of elderly people with uncaring family members who take their limited riches before throwing them out of their homes. A report by HelpAge India, a voluntary organisation working for abandoned and needy elderly people, reveals some shocking statistics. According to the report, one in three senior citizens is a victim of abuse in India.

“Some of the abuses we found are as brutal as severe beating of elderly people by their own sons, daughters and daughters-in-law,” states the 2012 report. It also says that in more than 50 per cent of abuse cases, the perpetrators are family members, with the son being the primary abuser in over 56 per cent of cases, followed by daughters in 23 per cent of cases. The most common reason for the abuse is property related.

Mathew Cherian, chief executive of HelpAge India says, “Earlier, people lived with their children when they were too old to work, but society is no longer parent-oriented and the rising trend we notice is that the elderly are moving out of their homes to places that cater to their needs.’’ But there aren’t enough old-age homes in India to house all the abandoned elderly people, he says.

More than half of India’s 1.1 billion population is younger than 25 and two-thirds is below the age of 35. The number of seniors is growing. By 2016, around 113 million people will be older than 60, and if the recent reports are any indication, a sizeable number of them will require an old-age home.

Stories about mistreatment of the elderly can be truly horrifying. A few years ago, there were reports in the Indian media about how police caught a man striking a deal with doctors and an organ-transplant broker to sell his unsuspecting father’s kidney, first taking him to hospital for a ‘check-up’ and then telling him he needed an operation. Doctors say such practices are commonplace.

Rampant physical abuse

According to an activist and charity worker, “All senior citizens we spoke to in Delhi said they had been verbally abused, while 33 per cent confided they had been physically abused – often beaten and tied to chairs.”

Last year, in the southern city of Hyderabad, the well-off family of a 75-year-old cancer patient decided to burn her alive at a crematorium because they did not want to pay for further treatment. She was saved when the crematorium staff noticed her stir and called police.

Elderly parents being abused and abandoned is not just an urban phenomenon. In rural India, the family system is eroding, with the younger generation increasingly heading off to cities with their spouses and their children to start a new life – without their parents or grandparents.

According to a 2012 survey by HelpAge India, less than 40 per cent of Indians now live with extended family. While Delhi has the highest number of senior citizens who own property, over the years they become meek and dependent on their children. And that is generally when problems arise.

Those who have worked in government service or for a reputed private company receive pensions, but a large majority of India’s population still work as farmers or day labourers. Once they are too old to work, they are forced to rely on their children or extended family for support.

There is a government-backed pension programme for the poor called the Indira Gandhi National Old Age Pension Scheme, which provides Rs200 a month to people over 60 who live below the poverty line, meaning they earn less than $1.25 (Dh4.59) per day. But the amount they receive is barely enough to get them food for a week. The government also approved a bill to increase the pension to Rs500 a month to those over the age of 80.

Mathew says, “At the policy level, the government needs to do a lot more to provide social security to the elderly... The long-term measure would be to offer them at least Rs1,000 per month.

“In 2007, the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Bill, which protects the rights of senior citizens, was passed in parliament. It provides an inexpensive and efficient system where the elderly could petition the administration to seek maintenance from their family.

“When the bill was passed, the government discussed plans to build at least one old-age home in all 629 districts in the country. The government said it would take care of elderly people if their family members were unable to look after them.”

But Mathew says one old-age home per district is not enough to address the problem. “Simple arithmetic explains that even if 100 people are accommodated in one old-age home, it would mean provision for just 62,900 elderly people. But what about the rest? There are thousands more out there.”

Nowhere to go

Mathew is worried about people like 70-year-old Kathleen Lama, originally from Darjeeling a city in West Bengal, who made her home on a patch of land in Nizamuddin, Delhi, several years ago. But she ended up on the streets after her husband died and her kids didn’t bother to look after her. There are thousands more like her on the roads of India, forgotten.

There are shelters for homeless elderly people run by charity organisations across India, but these shelters are usually packed to capacity.


Hukabhai Somabhai, 70, was brought to Atitna Ashirwad Vrudhashram, a crowded shelter for elderly homeless people, at Hirapur Chowkdi, some 20km from Ahmedabad, by volunteers who found him wandering in the streets. Parvatiben, 75, also lives in the shelter. She was found by volunteers roaming in the streets of Ahmedabad. Both had been abandoned by their families.

“With the joint family system withering away, the elderly are being abandoned,” Meira Kumar, a social justice minister in the Congress Party-led government was quoted as saying in 2007 when the bill to protect the elderly was presented in parliament.

The legislation calls for a three-month jail term if children do not look after their elderly parents. At the time, Meira said she hoped the penal provision would act as a deterrent.

There have been a few instances when the elderly have taken shelter under the law. A couple of years ago, a trial court ordered Delhi residents Sonu* and his wife Geeta* to vacate the home of Sonu’s mother, Kamla Devi*, after the elderly lady filed a complaint alleging that the couple “mentally tortured” her.

Kamla, who is in her mid 70s, said that she had built the house with her own money and, since she was a widow, had allowed her son and daughter-in-law to live with her out of love for them. However, they started harassing her and asking her for her property. Upset, she went to court and the court ordered the couple to vacate the house within a month. It also asked them to pay Rs3,000 per month as damages to Kamla from the time she filed the petition. Unfortunately, not many are as bold as Kamla, and the long wait due to the huge number of pending civil cases in Indian courts can tire most of the petitioners.

Seeking justice

In June 2012, the Delhi High Court issued an order to all court judges to give “special focus” to the cases involving senior citizens and ever since, courts in other cities are also taking similar steps.

Significantly, the bill states that a person would be disinherited if he or she fails to take care of their elderly parents. HelpAge has welcomed the legislation but says it may have little practical effect. Most parents are too demoralised, destitute or frail to begin a battle to get a ruling, HelpAge’s Mathew says. Also, “very few people will want to wash their problems in public,” he says.

But Mala Gupta* is one woman who is seeking redress under this law. After her husband Rajesh* passed away in 2010, she was confined to a single room in her own home by her son and his family who occupied the rest of the house. She was also being tortured by her son and his wife who wanted her to  transfer ownership of the house and the land to his name.

Fed up, she filed a complaint with the police, but that did not help. In fact, it only served to incense her son who unceremoniously threw her out of the house. Out on the streets Mala, who is over 60, initially took shelter in an ashram in Benaras, Uttar Pradesh. But with her daughter’s support, she has now filed a petition in the court, hoping her son will be evicted from her house.

One elderly gentleman who, sidelining his own trauma, has decided to reach out to assist others is Avikar Raj. The 66-year-old who was working in a law firm in the UK, returned to India keen to spend the last years of his life with his extended family in southern India. However, once his sizeable savings were exhausted they threw him out of the house, he says. With barely a few thousand rupees in his pocket Avikar, who was diagnosed with leukaemia, reached Delhi where, by sheer chance, he met Ravi Kalra who heads The Earth Saviours Foundation.

Ravi, who runs a home for the elderly and mentally challenged people in Delhi, took Avikar, who is a graduate from the London School of Economics, into his fold.
 
Avikar says, “When you retire and have no family life, you feel isolated and alienated. And I, who led a very active life, felt the impact much more. But I am desirous of spending the rest of my life in social work.” Today he helps Ravi manage the foundation.

According to a HelpAge India official, “There has been an increase in the number of senior citizens approaching us for jobs. Statistics available with job portals reveal that there has been a significant rise in the number of resumes posted by senior citizens on the websites.”

When asked his views on the increasing number of elderly people being abused in India, Gyan Prakash Pilania, a member of the opposition Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party and a social worker, has been quoted as saying, “Things have come to such a pass now that the old have to petition the government for care and help. What kind of a life is that?”

Those in old-age homes perhaps know the answer to Gyan’s question.

Holding on to hope

Sitting quietly on her bed at the old-age home where she lives, Kusum nods her head silently and wipes a tear with the corner of her sari when the caretaker of the home enquires if she is comfortable. She has few complaints. Staring blankly into the distance, her only hope is that her son will return to pick her up and take her back home. 

Clutching her walking stick, she gets up from her bed and makes her way to the window where she holds the bars and stares out. “I hope I’ll see my son at least once before I die,’’ she says, in a soft voice.

Rani, a volunteer who works at the old-age home walks up to her. “Don’t worry,’’ she tells Kusum. “We all love you and will look after you. And you can always consider me your daughter,’’ she says, before giving Kusum a warm hug.

*names changed to protect identity


 

Share your views

24 Comments
Show
  • T.A.PALANI

    30-Jan-2013 07:30

    At this time, I would like to thank the people who are taking care ofaged people in Orpanages, Old-age homes and etc. Though, an aged peoplewho are living in Orpanages, old-age homes and etc are not part of ourfamilies, we should visit those places to see them. So that, they willbe very happy. There are some old-age homes in Chennai called MercyHome, Little Sisters of the Poor and etc. I used to visit there to seethem. Those who wish to serve to the Humanity may visit such homes andprovide their service directly by helping them. May God bless agedpeople for peaceful life.

  • ..........

    28-Jan-2013 15:51

    Our parents give us life and taking care of us when we are small, nowits our time to pay them to take care of them during of there rest oftheir life.Even though they are not asking, it is our responsibility andlove them.

  • Soniya

    28-Jan-2013 14:18

    All these ungrateful children should be ashamed of themselves. Do notforget the fact that you will reach that age one day and I wish and praythat your children do the same to you. Just a short story...A son withhis wife and son were living with their father. Since the father wasfeeble he tends to spill tea and food on the table. So one day the wifegot so mad that she compalined to the husband..I cannot be alwayscleaning after your father and he has also broken a few plates and cupsetc. So the stupid son bought the father a wooden plate and cup and gota little table and told the father this is your dinning table and yourplate and cup and from today you will sit here. The father quietlyobeyed and always sat in his little table in the corner while the sonand family sat in the dinning table. The father always had a tear in hiseyes. Then one night whilst the son and his wife were asleep they heardlittle tapping noises and when they went out they saw their little sontapping onto a piece of wood and whe they asked him why - he said I ammaking plates and cups for you and mum so that when you grow old I couldput you in a little dinning table like you did to Grandpa. From that dayon the father was treated with utmost respect and back at the dinningtable. Your parents are your life...they were your eyes when youcouldn't see...your angels when you were in need...they held you whenyou couldn't walk - why are you doing this to them??? Sons....you canget plenty of wives but you HAVE ONLY ONE MOTHER & FATHER. If yourwives cannot respect your parents - how do you expect these selfishwomen to respect you....open your eyes...get a grip and stand up to yourparents - they are invaluble a priceless treasure. I lost my mum nineyears back....and how I miss her today. But, thank God I still have mywonderful dad - you is a great strength to our family and we love himunconditionally. We sisters fight amongst us wanting to keep him...Not aday goes by that I do not thank God for my wonderful parents. Ourhusbands are jewels as they love my dad like their own. I too have mymother-in-law and father-in-law - but for me the word in-law is notexist - THEY ARE MY LOVING MUM & DAD too. So please sons anddaughters love your parents...God will bless you.

  • Fahmeda

    28-Jan-2013 13:01

    Being a regular reader of Friday magazine, i am more touched with thetrue stories mentioned therein. whatever i read about the article on'Why India's youth are abandoning their elderly parents", it reallytouched me deep. I think Friday is doing excellent job by exposing tothe world such real life happenings. It may awake among us those who arenot bothering to cater elder members of our families. May all of us bebestowed with a sense and capability to work for social welfare inanyway possible. Fahmeda Sajad, Dubai

  • Sad indian

    26-Jan-2013 22:22

    Not so long ago many indian family had grand parents (mainly paternal)in their household. Now forget grandparents even parents do not havespace in their childrens home and heart. This reminds me of the saying"one can replace his spouse but not parents". Feld sad afterreading this article.

  • Vijin

    26-Jan-2013 22:08

    Karma is a real pain. Everything in the universe attains a balance byitself. Its nature's law. And by that law, these people who abandontheir parents will one day be abandoned by their children or worse. Andthey will pay the price in God's courtroom.

  • Abhilash Michael

    26-Jan-2013 17:47

    Really a disgrace for all the children; in tears after reading through,will it be possible for anybody to abandon their parents who hadpainstakingly brought'em up????? cannot believe, IS IT TRUE???? afterall they love they had imparted and this is what they get, remember yourchild will follow your own foot steps when you come of this age, 'GODWILL FORGIVE BUT TIME WILL NEVER FORGIVE AND THEIR WILL BE NO TIME TOREPENT AND REVISE YOUR DEEDS'

  • fahmeda

    26-Jan-2013 17:22

    it is really really heart-aching true story of different individuals...it really flooded my eyes... i wish i could ever become able to assistsuch individuals to spend the remaining years of their lives withhappiness and love.. :(

  • pathik dalal

    26-Jan-2013 17:15

    Its very sad to hear such stories. How a son/daughter can do such thingswith there own parents who gave them birth and gave better upbringingwith good education , and in old days this is what they get from therekids, Its a big shame on us that this happens in India, a country wherewe we always talk about our culture (sankriti)where we are being taughtsince childhood to respect our parents and teachers and elders. SuchSons and daughters should be boycott from society and also should bepunished with very hard punishment for life time.

  • maryam

    26-Jan-2013 16:27

    it not only about India but its happening almost every where....because people don't realize if today they will consider their parentsas BURDEN then tomorrow they will suffer from their children hands. ifeel sorry for all this...

  • Load more

Latest Comment

At this time, I would like to thank the people who are taking care ofaged people in Orpanages, Old-age homes and etc. Though, an aged peoplewho are living in Orpanages, old-age homes and etc are not part of ourfamilies, we should visit those places to see them. So that, they willbe very happy. There are some old-age homes in Chennai called MercyHome, Little Sisters of the Poor and etc. I used to visit there to seethem. Those who wish to serve to the Humanity may visit such homes andprovide their service directly by helping them. May God bless agedpeople for peaceful life.

T.A.PALANI

30 January 2013 10:34jump to comments