Opinion | Editorials
To enforce or ban attire is wrong
French President Sarkozy has found an easy target which misses the point.
- Gulf News
- Published: 23:29 July 11, 2009
The discussions in France are moving ahead on President Nicolas Sarkozy's eccentric plan to ban the burqa, the head-to-toe covering worn by a few Muslim women (no more than several hundred in all of France today).
The proposal is badly flawed in that it over-rides an individual's right to wear what they might wish, and assumes that the burqa is an imposition. This error was eloquently summed up by French Urban Affairs Minister Fadela Amara, who is a Muslim, when she said last week that a French court was right last month to deny citizenship to a Moroccan woman who wears the burqa, adding that she hoped the ruling would "dissuade certain fanatics from imposing the burqa on their wives".
French lawmakers should concentrate on considering whether such an imposition is wrong, not the clothing itself. By looking for an easy Muslim symbol to target, they will get themselves into the same mess that was created by France's 2004 law insisting on secular clothing for students. It managed to discriminate in favour of Christian and Jewish students by assuming that the wearing of crosses or stars of David was 'discrete' and therefore legal, but that headscarves were 'conspicuous' and therefore illegal.
More from Editorials
More from Opinions
Opinion Editor's choice
-
Threat of German amnesia
By Joschka Fischer, Special to Gulf News
Rarely has the country been as isolated as it is now. Hardly anyone understands its dogmatic austerity policy, which goes against all experience
-
Moral implication of America's security mindset
By Gordon Robison, Special to Gulf News
After a decade in which torture became official government policy, America’s moral standing when it comes to looking at other governments’ human rights failings is much-diminished
-
Europe's salvation lies in euro's demise
By Bruce Anderson
A return to national currencies is the only hope, but it won’t be easy or cost-free
Your turn
