Opinion | Columnists

Political discourse hits new low in India

The vacuum created by a lack of direction in the Congress and BJP has resulted in divisive elements muddying the waters with outrageous statements and allegations while ignoring the real issues

  • By Amulya Ganguli
  • Published: 20:00 November 7, 2012
  • Gulf News

To understand why Narendra Modi is dwelling on issues like Sonia Gandhi’s travel bills, Shashi Tharoor’s wife, Manmohan Singh’s silence — he called the Indian prime minister Maun (silent) mohan — during his election campaign, it has to be realised that the Gujarat chief minister can no longer play the communal card that was so useful to him earlier.

The run-up to the 2002 elections in the western Indian state was marked by Modi’s provocative ploy of uttering the full name of then chief election commissioner — James Michael Lyngdoh — in order to emphasise his “alien” roots. He went on to point out that both Lyngdoh and Congress president Sonia Gandhi are Christians.

As for Muslims, Modi mocked their propensity to marry four wives by saying, “Hum panch, hamare pachis” (We are five with 25 children) to underline their violation of family planning norms.

Modi also described the refugee camps for the victims of the 2002 riots as child-producing centres.

How effective this relentless baiting of minorities was for Modi and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) could be seen from the rise in the margin of victory of Maya Kodnani, who was recently convicted for instigating the riots, from 7,000 votes in 1998 to more than 60,000 in 2002. Five years later, the margin rose to 180,000 votes.

Considering, however, that Modi has since changed tack, stressing his development plank and even holding sadbhavna (goodwill) fasts in aid of social harmony, he is unable to whip up communal sentiments. He has had no alternative, therefore, but to fall back on issues like Sonia Gandhi’s travels abroad although he desisted from referring to her medical expenses lest this was considered too insensitive.

Crossing the line

However, his tactlessness was evident when he brought up the subject of Tharoor’s earlier removal from the external affairs ministry following allegations of his then girlfriend’s involvement in Indian Premier League financial irregularities. Not surprisingly, Modi’s question at a poll rally — “Has anyone seen a Rs50 crore [Dh33.65 million] girlfriend?” — drew a riposte from Tharoor that his wife was “priceless” and angry responses from women’s organisations.

The danger, however, of a descent into coarseness is that it generates more unrefined conduct. While the BJP’s Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi tried to outdo Modi’s lack of urbane sensitivity by suggesting that Tharoor could be made a minister for love affairs, the Congress’ ‘loose cannon’, as he once called himself, Digvijaya Singh, asked YouTube users to “search for Yashoda Ben”, who is supposed to be Modi’s spouse.

The lowering of the level of political discourse is not confined to Modi and his supporters and critics. While activist-turned-politician Arvind Kejriwal continues to be a “muckraker” as BJP president Nitin Gadkari said, Subramanian Swamy the president of the one-man Janata Party, has entered the mud pit with allegations of fraudulence against Sonia and Rahul Gandhi.

The apparent reason for the present murky scene is that neither of the two main parties — the Congress and the BJP — has been able to pull decisively ahead of the other in the race. The resultant vacuum has left enough scope for new entrants like Kejriwal and Co and habitual litigants like Swamy to muddy the waters.

A measure of the misgivings which prevail can be gauged from the fact that Anna Hazare, who is Kejriwal’s mentor, has expressed the apprehension that his protege can become “power hungry”. Hazare himself has re-entered the arena after a brief pause during which Kejriwal left his company.

Controversy

Now, Hazare has constituted another team along with the former chief of the army staff, General V.K. Singh, whose term ended under a cloud because of a controversy over his year of birth. It remains to be seen whether the general and the soldier (Hazare was once in the army) can prove to be as effective as the earlier group of activists initially were.

Unfortunately, none of this kerfuffle is expected to yield a clearer picture in the near future. While the expected Congress defeat in Gujarat may make the Manmohan Singh government nervous about pursuing reforms with any vigour, it is unlikely to be of much help to Modi in fulfilling his ambition of moving to the national stage because of the BJP’s internal problems.

For one, Gadkari’s embroilment in corruption will not give him much time for an organisational reshuffle. For another, the possibility of former Karnataka chief minister B.S. Yeddyurappa leaving the party will throw the BJP into further confusion.

The Congress, on its part, will be unable to take advantage of the disarray in the opposition ranks — the Left is demoralised while the BJP is a house in turmoil. First, because of the charges of corruption against Robert Vadra, Salman Khurshid, Virbhadra Singh and others and, secondly, because it will take time for the reforms to yield results.

— IANS

Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst.

Gulf News
Quick Links

  1. Business

  2. Sport

  3. The latest Entertainment news

  4. The latest Lifestyle stories

  5. Blogs

  6. Opinion

In Opinion

  1. Meet Our Writers

  2. Columnists

  3. Editorials

  4. Off the Cuff

  5. Your say

  6. Speak Your Mind

Latest Columns

  1. Biggest challenge since Tiananmen for China

  2. We still don’t know how bad can Ebola be

  3. Action against Daesh isn’t war

  4. New Modi doctrine for Indian foreign policy

  5. Europe’s Ukrainian soul

  6. Adaptive Learning can help students