Opinion | Editorials
Somewhere in Cuba that is forever America
The US apex court has had the courage to say denial of habeas corpus must stop.
- Gulf News
- Published: 00:01 June 14, 2008
The majority of Americans are opposed to the detention centre in Guantanamo. Both presidential candidates, the Democrat Barack Obama and the Republican John McCain, have said they would close it upon moving into the White House. And now the Supreme Court has dealt it a catastrophic ruling, the most serious blow yet to President George Bush's policy of holding prisoners indefinitely in a corner of Cuba without trial. It is the third time the Supreme Court has ruled against Bush on Guantanamo. On the previous two occasions, the administration and the Republican-controlled Congress changed the law to strip the detainees of their right to habeas corpus.
Bush cannot go to Congress this time because it is now controlled by the Democrats, who favour closing it. The Guantanamo camp, which was opened in January 2002 to detain terror suspects, has done America's image immense harm; it is worth noting that key allies Britain, France and Germany have called for its closure as have senior US politicians. The longer it remains open the darker will be the stain on America's reputation. The best weapon against terror is justice delivered not behind closed doors but in an open and transparent manner.
Guantanamo is a place where justice is denied which is why it was picked - to be beyond the jurisdiction of American courts. That has now changed. At last the Supreme Court has shown the courage to say the denial of habeas corpus must stop in the name of law. It may be that Guantanamo will be closed in the near future but there seems little indication that the Bush White House has any intention of shutting it down soon or releasing those who have been held there for years without charge. However we know now that American law does extend to that wretched place.
Opinion Editor's choice
-
Russia, China complicit in Syria carnage
By Fawaz Turki, Special to Gulf News
By their double veto at the UN, they have chosen to back the Al Assad regime that is already wet spaghetti
-
Two prime ministers in trouble
By Kuldip Nayar, Special to Gulf News
Gilani faces contempt of court charge while Singh encounters moral responsibility in 2G scam case
-
Moving towards honest democracy
By Vladimir Putin, Prime Minister of Russia
Russia needs to unbundle power and property and separate executive power from system of checks over it
Your turn
