Opinion | Editorials
No missile system is foolproof
What will safeguard Europe and America is good old-fashioned diplomacy
- Gulf News
- Published: 00:00 June 9, 2007
Vladimir Putin pulled the diplomatic rabbit out of the hat with his suggestion that a US missile defence system in Europe could be placed in Azerbaijan. Putin argued that a system based in the former Soviet republic would be more effective in combating missiles aimed at Europe and the US by so-called rogue states.
The Russian president has dramatically changed his tune in the space of a week. He raised the spectre of nuclear war with his comments before the G8 meeting, now he speaks of co-operation and seems to acknowledge that the American argument of placing missiles in Europe against rogue states is not without its merit. The Americans and Europeans were taken aback by Putin's comments. The proposed missile defence system, to be situated in the former Warsaw Pact countries of Poland and the Czech Republic, prompted fury in Moscow and fears of encirclement by Nato.
Now Putin is extending his hand in apparent friendship. There is considerable interest in the idea in Europe and America, not least because of public resistance to the proposals from some in Poland and the Czech Republic, so the idea of switching the system elsewhere has its attractions. But now the problems begin. Co-operation is welcome but who will have the ultimate say in manning the missiles, Moscow or Washington? Who defines what a rogue state is, Moscow or Washington? There are too may questions for security to be guaranteed.
What will safeguard Europe and America is not missiles but good old-fashioned diplomacy. No missile system is foolproof or even anywhere near foolproof. Placing faith in a missile shield is more than a little contradictory. It is downright dangerous, breeding a false sense of security and providing all the defensive capabilities of a modern-day Maginot Line.
More from Editorials
More from Opinions
Opinion Editor's choice
-
Egyptians must reject foreign meddling
By Tariq Ramadan, Special to Gulf News
Presidential election may turn out to be less a new chapter in a democratic future than an old chapter complete with a stage-managed outcome
-
Moderates may gift Egypt to Islamists
By Linda S. Heard, Special to Gulf News
Liberals cannot afford to sit at home or in cafes watching queues lengthen outside polling stations. They must quit complaining and vote with their feet
-
Is Al Maliki serious about democracy and more words?
By Mohammad Akef Jamal, Special to Gulf News
He is pushing towards a military showdown with the Kurds at a time when they are stronger than ever before
Your turn
