Opinion | Columnists
Joined at the hips by fear of terrorism
Pakistan and India should come round to the view that they owe it to South Asia's stability to take decisive action against all hues of extremism.
- By Kuldip Nayar, Special to Gulf News
- Published: 00:00 November 1, 2008
- Image Credit: Guillermo Munro/Gulf News
THERE is no terror, Cassius, in your threats," Julius Caesar tells him. Pakistan could have told India the same thing at the meeting of joint anti-terror mechanism: recent bomb blasts at Malegaon and Modasa were not the doing of "Muslims from across the border."
Nor did the Pakistani delegation point it out that India had its own Hindu terrorists, led by a woman and trained by some ex-army men belonging to an old military school. The meeting, fourth in the series, was "positive", although quiet.
On the day the representatives of India and Pakistan met at New Delhi, the Prime Ministers of the two countries discussed terrorism at Beijing. Both reiterated that they were committed to working together to clamp down on terrorist forces.
"Terror is a common enemy of both India and Pakistan," said Manmohan Singh of India and Yousuf Raza Gilani of Pakistan concurred with him. The equation between the two holds promise for the future. What creates doubts in the mind is that a similar exercise was gone over more than a year ago. But it never got translated into joint anti-terror mechanism. The army dragged its feet. General Pervez Muharraf was then the army chief. However, his successor General Ashfaq Parvez Kiyani has put the end of terrorism on top of his agenda, an essential pre-requisite for any development. This may mean the end of infiltrators into India.
But if the policy has changed the reasons are not difficult to comprehend. One, the terrorists have become a menace for Pakistan itself. But the most important development is the change in the attitude of the rulers. President Asif Ali Zardari is at the helm of affairs. His approach to Pakistan's problems with India is different from that of the earlier regimes. He wants to befriend India.
Hawk
I saw this happening from close quarters when I heard the National Security Advisers of the two countries. At a small dinner given by the Pakistan High Commissioner at Delhi, they said certain things which were unbelievable. India's National Security Advisor M.K. Nayaranan admitted that he was a hawk but had come around to believe what Singh told him: "India and Pakistan were destined to be together." I do not know what transpired between the two during official meetings but Pakistan's National Security Adviser Mahmud Ali Durrani told me that the talks were more successful than he ever expected.
It looks as if the clouds of hostility that overcast India and Pakistan are thinning. Both Singh and Zardari have reached some understanding on how to fight terrorism in the two countries when they met at New York.
Both Narayanan and Durrani were asked to prepare the ground which they did at Delhi. The joint mechanism will be built on it in the days to come. It is obvious that the different agencies operating in the two countries will have to fall in line. In the next few days, the Pakistani training camps, which are a sore point with India may be dismantled.
All these measures are laudable. But they are only the means, not the end by itself. The end is normal relations between the two countries. This is not possible until both curb radicals, Hindus and Muslims, in their own territory.
India, a secular polity, is under pressure. Hindutva is gaining ground. Despite their anti-national activities, New Delhi is reluctant to take action against Hindu nationalist groups which have spread all over.
It is already a bit too late because the politics of hate is spreading as has been seen in Bihar and Maharashtra where the lumpen are fighting on the streets.
This trend is reminiscent of MQM's violence in Karachi and it is tearing apart the society in both countries and creating fear in the minds of ordinary people. How will the joint mechanism check those who have communalised terrorism in India and politicised it in Pakistan?
The entire South Asia requires a common mechanism to fight the growth of disruptive tendencies. India had kept them in check with some courage and determination. But lately it looks as if politics has taken over because of the impending elections. India cannot fail South Asia when liberal, democratic values are beginning to matter in the region.
Strong state
For that reason, Islamabad cannot afford to talk to the Taliban in the North-Western Frontier Province and the federally administered tribal area. This would look like buying peace. It makes no sense to New Delhi if the Taliban are won over for the time being. They will resume pushing their archaic thinking after having consolidated themselves.
It is a pity that Nawaz Sharif, former Prime Minister, who is all for a strong and viable Pakistan, favours a settlement with the Taliban. He should have drawn a lesson from what has happened to Asfandyar Wali Khan, the NWFP leader. He, along with his family, has taken refuge in London because the Taliban tried to kill him and threatened to eliminate the entire family. They are against any liberal thought. Nawaz Sharif's Muslim League should stand by Pakistan Peoples Party to eliminate the Taliban who have a dream to rule both Pakistan and Afghanistan. The region's dream is different.
Kuldip Nayar is a former Indian High Commissioner to the UK and a former Rajya Sabha member.
More from Columnists
More from Opinions
Opinion Editor's choice
-
Syrian crisis and rumblings of a cold war
By Patrick Seale, Special to Gulf News
With their vetoes, Russia and China are saying they too have interests in the Middle East, which they are bent on protecting
-
Motives for a new regional alignment
By Marwan Kabalan, Special to Gulf News
The relationship between Iraq and Syria strengthened following the breakout of the uprising and withdrawal of US troops
-
Learning Arabic must not be seen as a compulsion
By Rabia Alavi, Special to Gulf News
Expatriates must see its inclusion in school curriculum as an invitation to integrate into Emirati society and an opportunity to access markets presently reserved for Emiratis
Your turn
