World | UK
Journalist wins legal test case over contacts
A British journalist won a legal test case over the confidentiality of reporters' contacts on Thursday, after judges ruled against a court order seeking all his notes for a biography of a former radical.
- Agenciees
- Published: 00:08 June 20, 2008
London: A British journalist won a legal test case over the confidentiality of reporters' contacts on Thursday, after judges ruled against a court order seeking all his notes for a biography of a former radical.
Civil liberties campaigners had feared the so-called "production order", obtained by Greater Manchester Police under anti-terrorism laws, could undermine the future of investigative journalism in Britain.
The order had required London reporter Shiv Malik to give police all his notes and source material for a book he was writing on Hassan Butt, a British-born Muslim who spent ten years inside radical Islamist groups.
To be reconsidered
Judges at the High Court in London said the order should be reconsidered and set a date later this month to decide what source material it should apply to.
They said the judge who issued the order at Manchester Crown Court was entitled to do so, but said the terms of the order that he made were too wide.
"A balance has to be struck between the protection of confidential material of journalists and the interest of us all in facilitating effective terrorist investigations," they said.
Malik said the ruling was a "victory for common sense".
"The High Court has agreed with the substance of our case, that investigative journalists should be allowed to maintain the confidentiality of their sources and their materials."
Malik said he would fight the revised order, which he expected to be limited to his notes relating to Butt.
News Editor's choice
-
Allies quit ruling coalition in Nepal
Political row could trigger months of street protests and violence
-
Qatar blaze 'started at nursery'
Fire killed 19 including 13 children, at Doha’s main shopping centre
-
Jagan jailed over illegal assets
Andhra Pradesh leader accused of corruption, cheating, conspiracy
