Region | Egypt
Activists decry death penalty trend
Opponents of capital punishment in Egypt argue it has had little effect on crime rate.
- By Ramadan Al Sherbini, Correspondent
- Published: 23:04 July 4, 2009
- Business tycoon Hesham Tala'at Mustafa, convicted of the murder of Lebanese singer Suzan Tamim, is one of Egypt's most high-profile personalities on death row. Rights activists have decried the increase in capital punishment cases in the country.
- Image Credit: EPA
Cairo: Alarmed by a sharp rise in the number of death sentences passed by the country's courts, human rights activists in Egypt have stepped up their campaign seeking abolition of capital punishment, which, they say, has failed to have the desired deterrent effect on the crime rate.
"The Egyptian authorities have to reconsider capital punishment, which has not succeeded in bringing down violence and crime in society," said Hafez Abu Saeda, a prominent rights activist.
"What would be the case if a death inmate was found to be innocent after his execution?" he said in remarks to Gulf News.
"My organisation is planning a series of seminars and workshops to educate the public and the officials concerned about the serious dangers involved in keeping the death penalty," added Abu Saeda, who is the chairman of the Egyptian Organisation for Human rights, a non-governmental group.
Over the past six months, Egyptian courts have sent more than 90 people to the gallows, the latest being business tycoon Hesham Tala'at Mustafa, and Mohssen Al Sukkari, an ex-policeman, who were convicted of the murder of Lebanese pop singer Suzan Tamim in Dubai in July 2008.
June has proved to be the month with the highest number of death sentences so far this year with 68 rulings. In comparison, a total of 70 death sentences were handed out in 2007 and 2008, according to legal experts. The spate of death sentences reflects spiralling violence in the Arab world's most populous country, say sociologists.
Earlier this year, Khalil Qeweita, an MP of President Hosni Mubarak's party, tabled a motion in parliament demanding the execution of rape offenders be broadcast on television "to deter would-be rapists". His suggestion has already earned the approval of a legislative committee and the censure of rights activists.
"I wrote to the Speaker of the Parliament asking him not to endorse this draft Bill, which contradicts Egypt's international obligations," Abu Saeda said.
Egypt is one of 14 countries in the world seen enforcing the death penalty on a large scale, according to the UN. Abduction, rape, murder and drug dealing are among the offences punishable by death under Egyptian law. "The recent death rulings were passed to deter the upsurge of crimes in Egypt," said Ahmad Abdul Rahman, a lawyer at criminal courts, attributing the surge in violence in recent years to "a lack of religious adherence and severe economic hardships". Around 40 per cent of Egypt's 80 million population are believed to live below the poverty line.
Growing tally: Prominent cases
Prominent among the cases culminating in death sentences in June were:
- On June 1, a criminal court in Giza, south of Cairo, sentenced an unemployed local man to death for killing the driver of a tok-tok (a three-wheeled cab)
- On June 7, a criminal court in northern Cairo condemned to death an engineer for killing his wife and two children
- On June 9, a court in Benha, north of Cairo, sentenced to death seven people for a killing spree over a clan feud
- On June 13, a criminal court in Beheira sentenced 24 people to death for killing 11 others in a dispute over a piece of land
- On June 14, a criminal court in Giza sent a couple to the gallows for killing their employer with the intent to commit theft
- On June 17, a criminal court in Cairo condemned to death a young man for killing two girls, one of them the daughter of Moroccan singer Laila Gufran, in an apartment near Cairo late last year
- On June 25, a criminal court in southern Cairo upheld death rulings earlier passed against construction mogul Hesham Tala'at Mustafa and ex-policeman Mohsen Al Sukkari for murdering Lebanese pop star Suzan Tamim in Dubai last year.
Ten people executed since start of this year
Since the start of 2009, ten people on death row have been executed, according to prison sources. There are no official figures yet.
The 10 executed were convicted of abducting and gang-raping a woman in the delta province of Kafr Al Shaikh. The court of cassation upheld the death sentence passed against them by a criminal court.
Convicts can stay for more than one year in prison before the execution is carried out.
Do you believe in capital punishment? Is it the right way to discourage people from committing crimes?
Your comments
I believe that those who show no mercy for their victims deserve no mercy in return.
Betty Carter
Austin,USA
Posted: July 05, 2009, 12:11
Both reason and social science have known, for a very long time, that murder rates are not how deterrence is established.
For example, look at crime rates. Some jurisdictions have high crime rates, some low - from year to year crime rates go up, down or stay, roughly, the same. In all of those circumstances, we know that some potential criminals are deterred from committing crimes by fear of sanction.
It is the same with all which deters, inclusive of the death penalty. Whether murder rates go up or down, whether they are high or low, I think there will be fewer net murders with the death penalty and more net murders without it.
Dudley Sharp
Houston Texas,USA
Posted: July 05, 2009, 09:43
Share this article
Popular in News
News Editor's choice
-
Ajtebi's phenomenal assent
The former camel jockey was at the peak of his powers when upstaging Garret Gomez
-
US pushing for more aid to Philippines
Obama administration eyeing $667m security assistance package
-
Mohammad launches H1N1 campaign
Shaikh Mohammad was the first one to receive the H1N1 vaccine.
