Entertainment | Visual Arts
From darkness to light
Chicago's new museum reflects the transparency inherent in the city
- By Edwin Heathcote, Financial Times
- Published: 23:01 June 25, 2009
Built on the edge of what was then the fastest growing city in the world, beside the railroad that made Chicago the hub of United States trade, on a heap of dirt piled from the remains of the city after the fire of 1871, the Art Institute of Chicago embodies the city's history.
Yet its stolid Beaux Arts façade is everything that the city's most famous architecture is not.
This is the city that invented the skyscraper, the city of industry, of the prairie, of the intricately clad, iron-framed behemoths that make its cityscape so recognisable.
Now, a light, steely and refined extension, which cost $294 million, has embedded the building back in its cultural context — and it has taken an Italian to do it.
Its architect, Renzo Piano, has become the pre-eminent museum designer of our time.
From the urban shock of Paris's Centre Pompidou to the delicacy of the Swiss Beyeler Foundation and the Texan Menil Collection, he has built a reputation as an architect of impeccable taste.
His strength is his willingness to defer to the art. He manages to deliver a blend of cool urbanity and faultless functionality.
In Chicago he has lived up to that reputation. The new Modern Wing, probably the last of this generation of US blockbuster museum extensions, holds the Art Institute's astonishing modern collection and, with more than 250,000 square feet of space, makes it the largest museum in the US after New York's Metropolitan.
Its delicate structure and sheer transparency open it out to the landscape and to the public. Centred on an airy top-lit atrium with galleries open to either side, it is something like a classical basilica section with nave and apses but light and filigree in its structure.
What Piano refers to as a “magic carpet'', a louvered roof, hovers above the whole structure, filtering out direct sun and binding the volumes together.
After the lightness of that central street, the galleries on the two lower floors fade a little. Well proportioned and well mannered, they fade entirely into the background; the architecture disappears.
But the naturally top-lit top-floor galleries, housing the major early Modernist works, are superb.
Floor-to-ceiling glazing keeps the city continually in the frame and while it frames the skyline, the architecture of the building remains uncharacteristically inconspicuous.
Neither in material nor form, space nor contrast does it grab you or surprise you.
The one element that exhibits any quirkiness is the long arcing bridge that sweeps up from Millennium Park to a free public sculpture terrace, giving long views on to the sparkling waters of Lake Michigan and back to the city skyline.
“Chicago,'' Piano tells me, “invented lightness, it invented transparency.'' The city's buildings, he continues, “are an expression of strength and light but also … fragility … and that is the story here''.
The iron-framed buildings, developed as a response to Chicago's fire, led to contemporary architecture.
Their strength enabled a minimal skeleton to replace masonry structures — windows could expand from floor to ceiling, floorplates could become deeper.
This is the architecture of today's city. But it was a German, Mies van der Rohe, who refined the language to its ultimate conclusion.
His Chicago buildings are the high point of purist Modernism. He expressed a darkness; his was never an architecture subservient to art.
Piano has dispensed with darkness. Now all is light. This is an exemplary museum that shows off the collection as well as it could, so it seems churlish to criticise — but it lacks a little depth.
Polite, discreet, classical, Piano has refined the architecture of Chicago into a beautiful ghost of itself but it has become immaterial and spectral.
Perhaps we have become so in thrall to art, to its expense and glamour, that, just as happened at New York's Museum of Modern Art, the architecture can only fade away.
Share this article
More from Visual Arts
More from Arts & Entertainment
Weekend Review takes an in depth look at the issues behind the news
Popular in Entertainment
-
Gallery
Bollywood celebwatch
A look at Bollywood's best and brightest stars in action
Entertainment Editor's choice
-
Katrina and Ranbir share dating secrets
Katrina Kaif and Ranbir Kapoor share their dating secrets
-
Brazilian supermodel Gisele can fly!
Brazilian supermodel completes first part of her helicopter flying exams
-
Adam Lambert's glam jam
Adam Lambert brings androgyny back on the title track from his album, For Your Entertainment
